The Results of Carpometacarpal Joint Arthrodesis of the Osteoarthritic Thumb in Younger Patients Using Memory Staples

Tomos Richards,David Newington

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1055/s-0040-1716613

2020-09-17

Journal of Hand and Microsurgery

Abstract:Fusion of the trapeziometacarpal joint is a good pain-relieving procedure in young and active individuals with symptomatic isolated arthritis of the thumb base.[<a href="#JR_1">1</a>] Many techniques have been proposed, but it is accepted that arthrodesis may be protracted and difficult to achieve. Indeed, failure of fixation is well-recognized and nonunion rates of up to 39% are described in the literature.[<a href="#JR_2">2</a>] We began using memory staples to revise nonunions and hardware failures associated with T-plates (as pictured in [<a href="#FI-1">Fig. 1</a>]) and quickly began extending their use to include primary fusions due to encouraging results.We conducted a review of 14 consecutive cases performed since 2012 using memory staples, of which three were revisions of failed T-plate and 11 were primary fusions. All cases were performed under regional anaesthesia with a tourniquet. A dorsal approach was used between abductor pollicis longus (APL) and extensor pollicis brevis (EPB). The joint was excised with an oscillating saw with minimal bony excision to preserve thumb height. Opposing cancellous bony surfaces were held with a temporary k-wire in a "neutral" position, ensuring not to extend the thumb and testing the position against the table-top. Drill holes were positioned using a jig, and guide pegs inserted, measured and checked. Staples were then inserted. The k-wire was removed after the first staple and a second staple was subsequently placed. Clinical images of this sequence are shown in [<a href="#FI-2">Fig. 2</a>].Postoperatively, the patients were immobilized in a plaster slab for 2 weeks and a thermoplastic "made to measure" splint for a further 4 weeks, allowing early protected mobilization.Thirteen males and one female underwent the procedure, with a mean age of 57 (range 27–64). All underwent regular high-demand activities and were therefore not felt to be suitable for trapeziectomy or prosthetic arthroplasty. All cases united successfully with a mean time to union of 70 days. No reoperations were noted at a mean follow-up of 28 months. We feel that the compressive effect of the staples across the whole of the fusion site leads to a superior environment for union to occur. Obtaining this osseous union can be difficult, but it is important for patient satisfaction.[<a href="#JR_3">3</a>] Using this technique has proved to be the most reliable and predictable method for the senior author than other previous methods, including locking T-plates.Other fixation methods such as k-wires and tension band wiring have been described, but these may have associated soft-tissue complications along with significant risks of nonunion.[<a href="#JR_2">2</a>] We feel that use of memory staples leads to quick and reliable union in trapeziometacarpal fusion. Having a relatively short follow-up period, subsequent procedures may be required for adjacent segment disease; however, we would expect this to be in line with other methods of fusion. We would recommend the use of this method for achieving union and patient satisfaction in trapeziometacarpal fusion.Publication Date:<br/>17 September 2020 (online)© . Thieme Medical and Scientific Publishers Private Ltd.<br/>A-12, Second Floor, Sector -2, NOIDA -201301, India