The Impacts of High-Performance Work System on Organizational Performance from the Perspective of Strategic Fit:A Fuzzy Set Qualitative Comparative Analysis
WANG Xiaoyu,CHENG Dejun,WU Jiaxuan
2023-01-01
Abstract:The exploration of high-performance work system(HPWS)emerged in the 1980s as a typology.Research on HPWS began to flourish in the early 21st century.As an essential component of strategic human resource manage-ment(SHRM),HPWS refers to a set of human resource practices combined to improve organizational performance.However,although many scholars have now explored the conceptual connotation,constituent dimensions,and potential mechanisms of HPWS,the core issues regarding the synergistic effects between different practices within HPWS and the system configuration of adaptation in specific external contexts are still relatively vague.According to the strategic fit theory,the implementation of HPWS should not only ensure the"internal fit"between different HR practices but also main-tain the"external fit"with other structural features of the company.Does the HPWS have a variety of different matches?What are the mechanisms for interaction between human resource practices within the same system architecture?How do companies choose the correct human resource practices for their characteristics?These unresolved questions call for fur-ther exploration of the internal and external matching nature of HPWS. Currently,mainstream research has mainly explored the composition and nature of HPWS from three perspectives:universalistic,configurational,and contingency.These three perspectives each make different assumptions about the internal matching and external influences of HPWS from different perspectives.In terms of theoretical structure,the above three per-spectives seem to have summarized all possible properties of HPWS.However,they lack further integration with each other.A single perspective alone does not give us a complete and correct understanding of the nature of HPWS.According to the efficient complementarity theory and systems view,the internal fit of HPWS needs to consider two aspects:(1)the possible multiple heterogeneous approaches among different human resource practices,and(2)whether there is a distinction between"peripheral"and"core"human resource practices in the different heterogeneous approaches.The internal alignment of HPWS should not only consider the possible heterogeneity of different human resource practices but also clarify whether there is a difference between"peripheral"and"core"human resource practices in different heterogeneous approaches.On the other hand,to make use of the strategic significance of HPWS,it is necessary to link HPWS with other structural charac-teristics of the company,especially the strategic orientation of the company. Therefore,this research explores the internal and external matching nature of HPWS by using fuzzy set qualitative com-parative analysis(fsQCA)and t-test,respectively,using 283 manufacturing companies in the eastern coastal region of China as the research sample.The research results show(1)the internal fit nature of HPWS.There is no single"best practice"with-in a complete HPWS,but it relies on the complementary and synergistic effects between different HR practices.(2)The inter-action between internal fit and external fit of HPWS.T-test results show a complex matching relationship between different types of HPWS and other company external factors.Among them,the high-investment HPWS is not commonly found in state-owned enterprises and is more suitable for firms that adopt the ambidexterity innovation strategy.The opportunity-driv-en HPWS is more suitable for resource-strapped firms,and its subtype teamwork HPWS is more commonly used by smaller firms.In contrast,the subtype employee-engagement HPWS is more frequently used by firms that adopt the exploratory in-novation strategy.The motivation-opportunity-driven HPWS is more general across all firm types,and its subtype motiva-tion-teamwork HPWS is more applicable to firms that adopt the exploitative innovation strategy. In sum,based on the current practical problems in implementing enterprise human resource management practices and the gaps in the existing human resource management theories,this research presents the research question of"how to match the organization's high-performance work system strategically".Based on the theoretical perspective and research methods of strategic human resource management,this research systematically discusses the nature of HPWS and the specific mecha-nism to achieve strategic matching.It puts forward three specific combinations of high-performance human resource management practices.