Intersections and Cultural Exchange: Archaeology, Culture, International Law and the Legal Travels of the Dead Sea Scrolls

Bernard Duhaime,Camille Labadie

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-62015-2_6

2020-09-18

Abstract:Since the discovery of the first rolls of parchment in 1947, the Dead Sea Scrolls have been the subject of various disputes not only of a theological and archaeological nature, but also of a cultural, political, and legal one. Currently held by Israel for the most part, these manuscripts are now at the heart of competing claims insofar as both Israel, Jordan and the Palestinian Authority claim ownership. In 2009, the exhibition of the manuscripts at the Royal Ontario Museum (Canada) was an opportunity to relaunch this decade-long and thorny debate, but failed to find a satisfactory solution. In this perspective, the present article aims at exploring the numerous legal issues raised by the question of the ownership of the Dead Sea Scrolls, more specifically with regard to the norms of international law. It also aims at highlighting how cultural heritage has become a highly political stake due to the involvement of States in their protection, and at exploring the role Canadian diplomacy and extra-judicial mechanisms could play in resolving complex restitution claims.