Hybrid manufacturing: a review of the synergy between directed energy deposition and subtractive processes

José Luis Dávila,Paulo Inforçatti Neto,Pedro Yoshito Noritomi,Reginaldo Teixeira Coelho,Jorge Vicente Lopes da Silva
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00170-020-06062-7
IF: 3.563
2020-09-22
The International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology
Abstract:Additive manufacturing (AM) is one of the pillars of Industry 4.0, where automation to create smart factories is the main target. The hybridization of processes is one of the leading strategies to implement a more flexible, efficient, and interconnected manufacturing environment. Nowadays, different researches are focused on the hybridization of metal AM and subtractive manufacturing (SM). Based on the working principles of AM and SM, it can be established that they are complementary processes. Hence, a synergy between them allows conceiving a unique process. As a result, the advantages are magnified, and the limitations of each one are minimized or eliminated. This review presents the latest developments, challenges, limitations, and future perspectives for the integration between directed energy deposition (DED) and SM. DED is a versatile AM process for metal parts fabrication, where the geometrical complexity is its main advantage. Nevertheless, the low surface quality and the difficult dimensional control of the parts create the need for post-processing. Traditional post-processing involves a higher production time, and the barriers cannot be completely overcome. Then, a hybrid process constitutes a powerful concept to combine both technologies efficiently, to produce complex parts with less waste of material and energy.
engineering, manufacturing,automation & control systems
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to effectively combine Directed Energy Deposition (DED) in Additive Manufacturing (AM) with Subtractive Manufacturing (SM) in order to achieve a more flexible, efficient and interconnected manufacturing environment. Specifically, the authors explore how to overcome the limitations of each when used alone and maximize their advantages through hybrid manufacturing technology, that is, integrating these two complementary technologies within the same workstation. ### Main Problems and Challenges 1. **Surface Quality and Dimensional Control**: - Parts produced during the Directed Energy Deposition process usually have low surface quality and difficult - to - control dimensional accuracy. These problems need to be solved through subsequent processing, but traditional post - processing methods will increase production time and cannot completely overcome all obstacles. 2. **Manufacturing of Complex Geometries**: - For metal parts with complex geometries, DED can provide a high degree of design freedom, but due to the above - mentioned quality problems, it still needs to use SM for finishing. Hybrid manufacturing can reduce material waste and improve energy efficiency while ensuring the quality of the final product. 3. **Automation and Integration**: - In order to achieve the goal of Industry 4.0, that is, to create smart factories, the integration challenges at the hardware and software levels must be solved. This includes developing workstations that can accommodate AM heads, milling tools and other measuring devices, and ensuring the synergy between these components. 4. **Thermal Behavior and Its Effects**: - During the DED process, non - uniform thermal expansion and contraction caused by rapid heating and cooling will lead to residual stress, which may further lead to cracks, fatigue fractures or deformations. Therefore, it is crucial to study how to optimize thermal management strategies to improve microstructure and mechanical properties. 5. **Real - Time Monitoring and Prediction**: - In order to further improve the performance of the hybrid manufacturing system, it is also necessary to study how to use advanced sensing technologies and data analysis methods to monitor process parameters in real - time and make adjustments based on this, thereby ensuring the consistency and reliability of product quality. In summary, this paper aims to propose a new hybrid manufacturing concept by comprehensively considering the characteristics of DED and SM, to meet the challenges currently faced by the manufacturing industry, and to provide guidance for future research and development directions.