Abstract:Scientific education provides a set of tools to make sense of a complex world by teasing out complicated cause-and-effect relationships, such as the elimination of effects of confounding factors in controlled experiments. There is evidence that depth of understanding of controlled experiments is lacking among undergraduate science students despite exposure to controlled experiments in courses. To examine the understanding of controlled experiments, we developed a two-tiered assessment that includes closed-ended and open-ended questions, with three types of questions, i.e., (i) a scientific scenario about a flawed drug study, (ii) an everyday-life scenario about flawed thinking regarding product effectiveness, and (iii) a direct question about explaining controlled experiments. Consistent with previous findings, we demonstrated that large percentages of students in introductory biology courses at both a research-intensive institution and a primarily undergraduate, minority-serving institution failed to recognize the need to account for confounds. Based on these findings, we tested the hypothesis that scientific literacy could be improved through a course-based intervention using an active learning framework focused on science as a process of evaluating alternative hypotheses. We found start-to-end-of-semester improvement in students' identification of unaccounted confounds with a scientific scenario in an intervention course but not in the control course. Interestingly, students in both the control and intervention courses showed improvement when tested with a scenario based on everyday life. The study findings suggest that a concerning number of college students may not account sufficiently for uncontrolled variables in real-life situations, and we present a widely applicable instructional strategy that improves on this broadly relevant scientific reasoning skill.

Iteration in an Inquiry-Based Undergraduate Laboratory Strengthens Student Engagement and Incorporation of Scientific Skills

Using a module-based laboratory to incorporate inquiry into a large cell biology course

An Investigative, Cooperative Learning Approach to the General Microbiology Laboratory

Authentic Inquiry through Modeling in Biology (AIM-Bio): An Introductory Laboratory Curriculum That Increases Undergraduates' Scientific Agency and Skills

Combining Inquiry-Based and Team-Teaching Models to Design a Research-Driven, Cross-Disciplinary Laboratory Course

Course-Based Undergraduate Research Experiences Spanning Two Semesters of Biology Impact Student Self-Efficacy but not Future Goals

Attending to experimental physics practices and lifelong learning skills in an introductory laboratory course

Scaffolded Instruction Improves Student Understanding of the Scientific Method & Experimental Design

An introductory biology research-rich laboratory course shows improvements in students' research skills, confidence, and attitudes

Interactive Notebooks Improve Students' Understanding of Developmental Neurobiology, Attitudes Toward Research, and Experimental Design Competency in a Lecture-Based Neuroscience Course

Undergraduates' lived experience of project-/problem-based learning in introductory biology

Adapting Undergraduate Biology to Include Science Practices by Teaching Students to Generate Scientific Explanations

The Benefits of Peer Review and a Multisemester Capstone Writing Series on Inquiry and Analysis Skills in an Undergraduate Thesis

Known Structure, Unknown Function: An Inquiry-based Undergraduate Biochemistry Laboratory Course

Motivating and Shaping Scientific Argumentation in Lab Reports

Improving Academic Performance, Belonging, and Retention through Increasing Structure of an Introductory Biology Course

Inquiry for the win: Fostering curiosity through a BINGO exercise in a longitudinally integrated clerkship

A course-based research experience: how benefits change with increased investment in instructional time

Teaching science writing in an introductory lab course

An Inorganic Chemistry Laboratory Technique Course using Scaffolded, Inquiry-Based Laboratories and Project-Based Learning

An Active Learning Intervention Based on Evaluating Alternative Hypotheses Increases Scientific Literacy of Controlled Experiments in Introductory Biology