Radomized comparative study of hepatocellular carcinoma with extensive portal vein tumor thrombus treated by TACE combined with or without endovascular implantation of iodine-125 seeds strand
Zhu-ting FANG,Zhi-ping YAN,Jian-jun LUO,Qing-xin LIU,Xu-dong QU,Wen ZHANG,Ling-xiao LIU,Lin-lin WU,Min-Jie YANG,Jian-hua WANG
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3877/cma.j.issn.2095-5782.2013.01.004
2013-01-01
Abstract:Objective To compare the therapeutic effect of TACE combined with or without endovascular implantation of iodine-125 seeds strand for hepatocellular carcinoma ( HCC) with extensive portal vein tumor thrombus(PVTT)with randomized design.Methods From May-2011 to Dec 2012,62 patients of HCC with extensive PVTT who received TACE were randomized divided into group A ( conbined with , 30 cases)and group B(without,32 cases)endovascular implantation of iodine-125 seeds strand were analyzed retrospectively .TACE was performed after the iodine-125 seed strand implanted in the target segment of PVTT.Adverse events , laboratory tests and abdominal constrast CT results between two groups were compared.Kaplan-Meier method was used for analyzing for survival rate .Results The objective remission rate of lesions was 10.0%(CR in 1 and PR in 6)in group A and 28.1%(CR in 2,PR in 7)in group B(χ2 =3.259,P=0.071).The mean number of iodine-125 seed was 20.4 ±4.4(14-32) for every patient.The recanalization rate of portal vein was 28.1%in group B higher than 0 in group A(χ2 =7.734,P=0.005). Technical success rate was 100.0% for implantation of iodine-125 seeds strand in the target segment of PVTT.No serious procedure related complications occurred in two group .The mean and median survival time was(153.8 ±9.9) d(95%CI:134.5-173.1) and(150.0 ±10.9) d(95%CI:128.6-171.4) in Group A and(221.5 ±19.2)d 95%CI:183.8-259.1)and(190.0 ±24.7)d 95%CI:141.6-238.4)in Group B, respectively(χ2 =10.973,P=0.001)(HR(A︰B) =2.577,95%CI:1.437-4.623,P=0.001).The 90, 180,360 d cumulative survival rates were 89.7%,28.7%and 0 in group A and 96.8%,56.0%and 15.2%in group B,respectively.In group with recanalization of portal vein (group B1,9 cases),the mean and median survival time were(306.9 ±45.6)d(95%CI:217.5-396.2)and(264.0 ±41.7)d(95%CI:182.3-345.7), respectively and the 90,180,360 d cumulative survival rates were 100.0%,87.5%and 40.0%,respectively. While in group without recanalization of portal vein (group B2,23 cases),the mean and median survival time were(189.5 ±16.5) d (95%CI:157.2-221.9) and (175.0 ±20.4) d (95%CI:134.9-215.1), respectively and the 90,180,360 d cumulative survival rates were 95.5%,43.2%and 6.4%,respectively. There was statistically significant difference between two groups (χ2 =5.105,P=0.024)(HR(B2︰B1) =2.960,95%CI:1.100-7.969,P=0.032).Conclusion TACE combined with endovascular implantation of iodine-125 seeds strand is an effective treatment for HCC with extensive PVTT .