Abstract:Journal of Educational Computing Research, Ahead of Print. The study aimed to examine the learning effects of integrating various game elements into game-based learning materials to enhance learning for learners of different age groups. Two sets of game-based music learning materials were designed. The version with full game characteristics was developed with a narrative story, diverse game behaviors, and game mechanisms, while the simple design version kept basic game behaviors only for game interaction, and removed other game-based elements. A total of 50 young students and 41 adults were invited to participate in the experiment and separately use the two versions of the game-based materials. In order to understand how their performance changed and their reflections on the use of the game-based learning materials, a pre- and post-test, questionnaire and interview were conducted, and the data were analyzed. Despite learners in various age groups having different preferences regarding the game design, the statistical analysis revealed that the simple version helped the learners of both age groups to achieve better learning performance than the full version. The game-based environments proved to be helpful for promoting students' learning motivation and performance, but the results suggest that instead of designing educational games with as many gamification elements as possible, game developers should take learners' cognitive learning load and information processing ability into consideration when developing games. The game elements could be refined through reducing overly complicated game mechanisms and keeping the basic game-like interaction so as to achieve both the instruction purpose and gameplay engagement.

Gamification and Formal Practice: A Pilot Study on Gamification’s Contributions to Kindergarten Students’ Musical Practice

Designing and Developing a Gamified App for Enhancing Independent Practice in K-12 Music Education

Gamifying Music Education: An Appealing and Engaging Method of Practice for Teenagers

Gamification and mobile learning: innovative experiences to motivate and optimise music content within university contexts

Gamified Learning Intervention to Promote Music Literacy and Creativity in Elementary Music Education

Can Gamification Assist Learning? A Study to Design and Explore the Uses of Educational Music Games for Adults and Young Learners

Self-Determination Theory and Children’s Singing Games In and Out of the Classroom: A Literature Review

Exploring the effects of using various designs of game-based materials on music learning

Exploring the Implementation Pathways of "Singing Game" Activities in Lower Primary Music Education

Practice and learning the piano: Motivation and self-regulation

The support of autonomy, motivation, and music practice in university music students: A self-determination theory perspective

A Practice for the Design of Interactive Multimedia Experiences Based on Gamification: A Case Study in Elementary Education

Rockstar teaching: Blended informal music learning in an elementary ukulele club

Practices, purposes and challenges in integrating gamification using technology: A mixed-methods study on university academics

At the intersection of belief and practice: A mixed-methods study of elementary general music educator praxis

Design music games based on the play of folk games to create excitement for preschool children 5 – 6 years old

A qualitative investigation of student experience in a gamified course at the Open University of Mauritius

Gamification as technology enabler in SEN and DHH education

Gamification of Virtual Language Learning: A Case Study with Thai Undergraduate Students

An Investigation of Digital Game-Based Learning Software in the Elementary General Music Classroom

Gamification in foreign language teaching: A conceptual introduction