The Effects of Emotional Working Memory Training on Worry Symptoms and Error-Related Negativity of Individuals with High Trait Anxiety: A Randomized Controlled Study

Salahadin Lotfi,Richard T. Ward,Maryam Ayazi,Ken P. Bennett,Christine L. Larson,Han-Joo Lee
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10608-020-10164-7
2020-10-31
Cognitive Therapy and Research
Abstract:Trait anxiety is characterized by impaired gating of threat from working memory (WM), allowing unnecessary maintenance of anxious cognitions. Improving filtering efficiency of threatening information through computerized WM training might reduce intrusive, worrisome thoughts.
psychology, clinical
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to explore the effects of Emotional Working Memory Training (EWMTraining) on worry symptoms and Error - Related Negativity (ERN) in individuals with high trait anxiety. Specifically, through a randomized controlled trial design, the researchers compared the effects of high - intensity (high - potency) emotional n - back task training with low - intensity (low - potency) 1 - back task training in improving attention control, working memory capacity, working - memory filtering efficiency, and reducing trait anxiety and worry symptoms. The main objective of the study was to verify whether emotional working memory training can effectively improve the cognitive function of individuals with high trait anxiety and alleviate their anxiety symptoms. ### Research Background Trait Anxiety is characterized by impaired working memory (WM) screening function for threat information, resulting in the persistence of unnecessary anxious cognition. Improving the screening efficiency for threat information through computerized WM training may help reduce intrusive and worrying thoughts. Therefore, the researchers designed an experiment to evaluate the effects of different - intensity emotional WM training on individuals with high trait anxiety. ### Method Overview - **Participants**: 322 participants were recruited from the University of Wisconsin - Milwaukee and its surrounding areas, and finally 49 eligible participants were included in the study. - **Grouping**: Participants were randomly assigned to the high - intensity emotional WM training group (tWMT, using an emotionally - adaptive dual n - back task) or the low - intensity control WM training group (cWMT, using an emotionally - non - adaptive dual 1 - back task). - **Training**: Participants underwent 9 training sessions at home, with a maximum of 5 sessions per week. - **Assessment**: At three time points, namely baseline (BL), post - training (PT), and 1 - month follow - up (FU), participants completed questionnaires and computerized cognitive tasks, including the Flanker task, the Emotional Change Detection Task (CDT), and the Automated Complex Span Tasks (ACPT). ### Main Results - **WM Training Performance**: The average WM training gain index in the high - intensity training group (tWMT) during the 9 training sessions was significantly higher than that in the low - intensity training group (cWMT), indicating that the high - intensity training group made greater progress during the training process. - **Worry Symptoms and Trait Anxiety**: Multilevel model analysis showed that worry symptoms (total PSWQ score) in the high - intensity training group were significantly reduced after training (PT), while the low - intensity training group also showed a similar reduction at follow - up (FU), but the effect was not as significant as that in the high - intensity training group. ### Conclusion The research results indicate that emotional working memory training can improve attention control, working memory capacity, and working - memory filtering efficiency in individuals with high trait anxiety, and can also alleviate their worry symptoms. These findings support the development of cognitive interventions for people with high trait anxiety or worry symptoms, either as an independent treatment or as an adjunctive treatment.