Abstract:Abstract Territorial animals often use signals to advertise territorial occupancy within their larger home ranges. Songbirds are among the best-studied territorial signaling taxa, and when competitors start singing during a territorial intrusion, residents usually show elevated spatial and vocal responses. These responses could be used by intruders and distant eavesdroppers to predict future responses or to compare responses across competitors. Yet, the extent to which responses of a resident to a territorial intrusion predict its future responses and its overall spatial behavior (home range) within a neighborhood is less well understood. We used wild great tits ( Parus major ) as a model species in repeated song playback trials, simulating territorial intrusions combined with radio-tracking before and during playback trials. The time spent close to the loudspeaker in response to an initial simulated intrusion predicted the same response variable during a second simulated intrusion on the next day, whereas singing activity during the first simulated intrusion did not predict singing during the second simulated intrusion. We also show that more explorative males (as determined by a novel environment test) and males with smaller home ranges sang more and spent more time near the loudspeaker in response to both simulated intrusions. Thus, by probing residents, intruders can obtain reliable information about subsequent response probabilities, while eavesdroppers from a distance, who can use auditory information only, would not receive sufficient predictive information. Our findings also suggest that males with larger home ranges are more tolerant toward intruders, which could reflect a trade-off between tendencies to respond strongly and to range widely. The lack of predictability of singing activity with regard to responses to future intrusions might explain why territorial animals continuously exchange vocal signals and regularly foray into neighboring territories, as a way to obtain regular information updates. Significance Statement Animals use experience from interactions with conspecifics in their future decision making, such as mate choice and strategies for conflict resolution. The value of such information depends in part on the predictability of the future behavior of that conspecific. In songbirds, territorial individuals respond to intruders by approach and signaling. Here, we tested in radio-tagged great tits ( Parus major ) if territorial responses are predictable and are affected by individual and environmental factors. We show that the time spent near the simulated intruder was more predictable than singing activity and that birds with larger home ranges showed weaker responses. These findings suggest that information based on such spatial responses is more useful for future decision making, as compared to vocal information, and that distant eavesdroppers will thus receive less reliable information. Limited predictability may explain why territorial animals continuously exchange vocal signals and foray into neighboring territories, providing opportunities for regular information updates.

The influence of social-grouping on territorial defense behavior in the black-crested titmouse (Baeolophus atricristatus)

Prior territorial responses and home range size predict territory defense in radio-tagged great tits

Sex-dependent recognition and behavior against nest predators and brood parasites by Chestnut-capped Blackbird Chrysomus ruficapillus

The effect of offspring value on variation of nest defense intensity in gray catbirds (Dumetella carolinensis)

A classic question revisited in red-winged blackbirds: disentangling confounding hypotheses surrounding parental investment theory and nest defense intensity

Recognizing interspecific dominance signals? Blue tits adjust nest defence based on great tit's black bib size

Influence of social and physical environmental variation on antipredator behavior in mixed-species parid flocks

Territorial scent-marking effects on vigilance behavior, space use, and stress in female Columbian ground squirrels

Behavioural traits modulate the use of heterospecific social information for nest site selection: experimental evidence from a wild bird population

Causes and consequences of inverse density-dependent territorial behaviour and aggression in a monogamous mammal

Aggressive responses to rivals depend on the interaction between the vocal traits of territory-holder and mimicked intruders in a miniature tropical frog

Genetically identical mice express alternative reproductive tactics depending on social conditions in the field

Fight or Flight: Geographic Variation in Antipredator Defenses by Cinereous Tits

Size matters: Natural experiments suggest the dear enemy effect is moderated by pack size in African wild dogs

Developmental stage‐dependent effects of perceived predation risk on nestling tree swallows (Tachycineta bicolor)

Testosterone induces a female ornament followed by enhanced territoriality in a tropical songbird

Kinship, dear enemies, and costly combat: The effects of relatedness on territorial overlap and aggression in a cooperative breeder

Geographical Variation in Nest Defense among Cinereous Tit Populations in China

Exploration behavior differs between Darwin's finch species and predicts territory defense and hatching success

The matador bug’s elaborate flags deter avian predators

Nest defence behavioural reaction norms: testing life-history and parental investment theory predictions