Abstract:The 21st Century Cures Act Final Rule (Final Rule) increases patient access to their health records but raises concerns about distress and misunderstanding of automatically released results and documentation. Little is known about genetic counselors' (GCs') experiences with the Final Rule. In Fall 2023, we conducted a cross-sectional survey of U.S. GCs about the Final Rule's perceived impact on practice and assessed if being the ordering versus non-ordering provider for genetic testing affected perceptions of Final Rule-related changes. GCs (n=102) reported demographic and workplace characteristics, institutional policy changes, workflow changes, and perceived patient harms and benefits due to the Final Rule. To compare ordering and non-ordering providers, we conducted Fisher's exact tests for categorical variables and trend tests for ordinal variables. Open response questions elicited examples of positive and negative patient impacts, the effects of patient characteristics, and practice changes in response to the Final Rule. Twenty-seven GCs were ordering providers and 66 were non-ordering providers. Relative to ordering providers, non-ordering providers expressed stronger agreement with statements indicating concern about the emotional impact on patients reviewing results or notes without support (P=0.002, 33% vs. 51% strongly agree), patients misunderstanding or misinterpreting results (P=0.025, 44% vs. 70% strongly agree), and patients contacting the inappropriate party to discuss results (P=0.023, 19% vs. 48%). Agreement with the statement "patients have more knowledge/context/questions at our disclosure session due to previous results review" also differed by ordering provider status (P=0.007). In open responses, GCs expressed concerns about patients' strong emotional reactions, patients misinterpreting results, workflow disruptions, and widening health disparities. Benefits included patients' ability to be reassured, informed, or empowered earlier; ease of sharing genetic and other health information; and more efficient workflow due to automatic release of results. These results emphasize the importance of clear communication within health systems and between patients and providers.

Ethical Considerations on Pediatric Genetic Testing Results in Electronic Health Records

Confidentiality, privacy, and security of genetic and genomic test information in electronic health records: points to consider

Genetic Testing Behavior and Reporting Patterns in Electronic Medical Records for Physicians Trained in a Primary Care Specialty or Subspecialty.

When Parents Request Nondisclosure: Rights of Adolescents to Access Their Health Information and Implications of the 21st Century Cures Act Final Rule

Clinician perspectives on policy approaches to genetic risk disclosure in families

Primary Care Providers' Experiences With an Active Elective Genetic Testing Program

Standards-Based Clinical Decision Support Platform to Manage Patients Who Meet Guideline-Based Criteria for Genetic Evaluation of Familial Cancer

Variation in pediatric and adolescent electronic health data sharing practices under the 21st Century Cures Act

Parents' and patients' perspectives, experiences, and preferences for germline genetic or genomic testing of children with cancer: A systematic review

Familial communication and cascade testing following elective genomic testing

Narrative review on ethical and psychological issues raised by genetic and genomic testing in pediatric oncology care

Adopting a Point-of-Care Model for Genetic Testing in Children With Developmental Delays: A Case Report

Preimplantation Genetic Testing for Polygenetic Conditions: A Legal, Ethical, and Scientific Challenge

Factors Impacting Intent to Share Multigenic Cancer Testing Results in a Community Hospital Setting

Ethical considerations in prenatal genomic testing

Genetic testing in psychiatry, the perceptions of healthcare workers and patients: a mini review

A Seven-Year Retrospective Assessment Evaluating the Effectiveness of Electronic Consultation (e-Consult) Service in Genetics

Psychological and ethical issues raised by genomic in paediatric care pathway, a qualitative analysis with parents and childhood cancer patients

Familial genetic risks: how can we better navigate patient confidentiality and appropriate risk disclosure to relatives?

Navigating the Impact of the 21st Century Cures Act Final Rule: A National Cross-Sectional Survey of U.S. Genetic Counselors

Parent Perspectives on Electronic Health Record-Based Social Needs Screening and Documentation: A Qualitative Study