The image of the City on social media: A comparative study using “Big Data” and “Small Data” methods in the Tri-City Region in Poland

Jianxiang Huang,Hanna Obracht-Prondzynska,Dorota Kamrowska-Zaluska,Yiming Sun,Lishuai Li

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.landurbplan.2020.103977

IF: 8.119

2021-02-01

Landscape and Urban Planning

Abstract:"The Image of the City" by Kevin Lynch is a landmark planning theory of lasting influence; its scientific rigor and relevance in the digital age were in dispute. The rise of social media and other digital technologies offers new opportunities to study the perception of urban environments. Questions remain as to whether social media analytics can provide a reliable measure of perceived city images? If yes, what implication does it hold for urban planners? This paper describes a study on the perception of city images using a combination of "big data" and "small data" methods in the Tri-City Region in Poland. The aims were to 1) test the hypothesis whether social media analytics can elicit Lynchian elements of city image in consistency with conventional methods, and 2) develop and evaluate social media-based indicators of Imageability for planning practice. Geo-tagged images and texts were collected from Instagram and Twitter, two popular social media platforms in Poland. Text-Mining, Image Processing, Clustering Analysis, Kernel Density Estimation, and Sentiment Analysis were used. Results were compared with benchmarks constructed from official GIS database, questionnaire responses and sketch maps. "District", "landmark", and "path" identified on social media were in good agreements with benchmarks, less so for "edge" and "node". Two social media-based indicators have influenced the perception of a place: Instagramability, the frequency of a place captured on Instagram, was linked to its perception as an architectural landmark and tourist attraction, while Twitterability, the frequency of a place mentioned on Twitter by name, was linked to its perceived niceness and relevance to everyday life of communities. Methods developed in this study have theoretical and practical implications for urban planners.

environmental studies,ecology,geography, physical,regional & urban planning,urban studies

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is how to clinically distinguish unilateral breast edema caused by congestive heart failure (CHF) from inflammatory breast cancer (IBC). This problem is important because the two may be very similar in clinical manifestations, especially when breast edema occurs unilaterally, which may lead to misdiagnosis and then affect the choice of treatment plan and the prognosis of patients.

Specifically, the paper shows the challenge of this differential diagnosis through a case report. The patient in the case was a 69 - year - old woman who was admitted to the hospital due to suffering from multiple diseases such as pulmonary hypertension for a long time. The main symptoms included dyspnea, pitting edema of both lower extremities, and progressive enlargement of the right breast, accompanied by an orange - peel - like appearance and pitting edema. Since these symptoms were very similar to those of inflammatory breast cancer, in the preliminary diagnosis, the doctor suspected that the patient might have inflammatory breast cancer. However, further imaging examinations (such as full - field digital mammography, digital breast tomosynthesis, ultrasound examination, etc.) showed that there was skin thickening, Cooper's ligament thickening and edema in the patient's right breast, but no obvious mass was found. Combining the patient's history of heart failure and her good response to the standardized treatment of heart failure, the final diagnosis was unilateral breast edema caused by heart failure.

The paper also reviewed relevant literature, summarized the reports of other similar cases, and discussed the key points of differentiating unilateral breast edema caused by heart failure from other diseases causing breast edema, emphasizing the importance of correct diagnosis for avoiding unnecessary examinations and treatments.