Abstract:Particulate matter (PM), while not an emerging contaminant, remains the primary labile substrate for partitioning and transport of emerging and known chemicals and pathogens. As a common unit operation and also green infrastructure, clarification basins are widely implemented to sequester PM as well as PM-partitioned chemicals and pathogens. Despite ubiquitous application for urban drainage, stormwater clarification basin design and optimization lacks robust and efficient design guidance and tools. Current basin design and regulation primarily adopt residence time (RT) as presumptive guidance. This study examines the accuracy and generalizability of RT and nondimensional groups of basin geometric and dynamic similarity (Hazen, Reynolds, Schmidt numbers) to scale clarification basin performance (measured as PM separation and total PM separation). Published data and 160,000 computational fluid dynamics (CFD) simulations of basin PM separation over a wide range of basin configurations, loading conditions, and PM granulometry (particle size distribution [PSD], density) are examined. Based on the CFD database, a novel implementation of machine learning (ML) models: decision tree (DT), random forest (RF), artificial neural networks (ANN), and symbolic regression (SR) are developed and trained as surrogate models for basin PM separation predictions. Study results indicate that: (1) Models based solely on RT are not accurate or generalizable for basin PM separation, with significant differences between CFD and RT models primarily for RT < 200 hr, (2) RT models are agnostic to basin configurations and PM granulometrics and therefore do not reproduce total PM separation, (3) Trained ML models provide high predictive capability, with (R2) above 0.99 and prediction for total PM separation within ±15%. In particular, the SR model distilled from CFD simulations is entirely defined by only two compact algebraic equations (allowing use in a spreadsheet tool). The SR model has a physical basis and indicates PM separation is primarily a function of the Hazen number and basin horizontal and vertical aspect ratios, (4) With common presumptive guidance of 80% for PM separation, a Pareto frontier analysis indicates that the CFD-ML augmented SR model generates significant economic benefit for basin planning/design, and (5) CFD-ML models show that enlarging basin dimensions (increasing RT) to address impaired behavior can result in exponential cost increases, irrespective of land/infrastructure adjacency conflicts. CFD-ML applications can extend to intra-basin retrofits (permeable baffles) to upgrade impaired basins.

Physically-Based Particle Size Distribution Models of Urban Water Particulate Matter

Particle Size Distribution Mathematical Models and Properties of Suspended Solids in a Typical Freshwater Pond.

Particle Size Effect in Urban Road-Deposited Sediment Wash-Off Process: Physical Experiments and Cellular Automata-Based Modeling

Event-based size distributions of particulate matter transported during urban rainfall-runoff events

Determination of Particle Size Distribution by Multi-Scale Analysis of Acoustic Emission Signals in Gas-Solid Fluidized Bed

Modelling Particle Size Distribution Dynamics in Marine Waters

Feasibility Analysis of a Method for Physical Source Apportionment of PM2.5 Based on Particle Morphology and Size Distribution

Research on representation of particle size distribution for standard sands

Comparison of alternative soil particle-size distribution models and their correlation with soil physical attributes

Particle size distribution of total suspended sediments in urban stormwater runoff: Effect of land uses, precipitation conditions, and seasonal variations

Characterization of road-deposited sediment wash-off and accurate splitting of initial runoff pollution in heterogeneous urban spaces

Integrated method of wavelet packet analysis and K-OPLS and its application in measurement of particle size distribution

A CFD-ML augmented alternative to residence time for clarification basin scaling and design

A Comprehensive Study on the Validation and Application of Multi-Lognormal Distribution Models for Atmospheric Particles

Transport and solubility of Hetero-disperse dry deposition particulate matter subject to urban source area rainfall–runoff processes

Measuring sediment loads and particle size distribution in road runoff: Implications for sediment removal by stormwater control measures

Empirical Model for Estimating Vertical Concentration Profiles of Re-Suspended, Sediment-Associated Contaminants

Development of Prediction Models for Particle Size Composition on Urban Road Surfaces

Effect of morphological properties on the particle size distribution measurements and modelling of porous and nonspherical aerosol behaviour

Optimization of suspended particulate transport parameters from measured concentration profiles with a new analytical model

Particle size distribution at Ocean Station Papa from nanometers to millimeters constrained with intercomparison of seven methods