Abstract:Proton exchange membrane hydrogen fuel cell (PEMFC) deployment is presently limited by the high material cost of oxygen reduction reaction (ORR) electrocatalysts at the cathode. Developing low-cost, earth-abundant alternatives for use in acidic environments presents a material stability challenge, especially for long-term device operation. Platinum (Pt)-based materials are used in typical commercial PEMFC cathode formulations due to their simultaneous high performance and long-term stability despite the prohibitively high material cost. Developing lower-cost, longer-life catalyst materials based on earth abundant transition metals can accelerate the adoption of PEMFC technology. The impact of potential, current density, and local microenvironment has been shown to cause degradation of non-Pt materials but standard ex situ measurements can only probe surface restructuring and cumulative dissolution after operation. Material-specific degradation mechanisms that are strong functions of the operating conditions cannot be ascertained without in situ quantification of material degradation under PEMFC-relevant conditions. Information about the degradation pathways of these non-precious catalysts can assist with material design for devices; however, most efforts towards developing an in-situ understanding of PEMFC cathode catalyst degradation under operating conditions are generally limited to Pt-based materials. Extensive in situ characterization has revealed Pt-specific mechanistic information about corrosion pathways as well as conditions that exacerbate Pt alloy leaching. It has been hypothesized that the Pt degradation processes are related to oxide formation under potential cycling. With this critical in-situ information, Pt conditioning protocols have been developed to enhance material lifetime; however, investigations on non-precious materials are less common. Insights into non-precious catalyst degradation in PEMFC operating conditions are not as well-established but could be essential in enabling low-cost materials for commercial use. There is a need for more insights into a vast array of materials which necessitates the development of faster, preferably benchtop techniques for degradation analysis. In this work, we use an in situ electrochemical flow cell assembly and coupled it with an inductively coupled plasma-mass spectrometer (ICP-MS) to quantify the loss of material in real time for several non-Pt materials under reaction conditions. The flow cell is fed by a peristaltic pump at 2.5 mL/min of gas-saturated acidic electrolyte for optimal mass transport. The cell has a three-electrode configuration with a compression-mounted metal foil working electrode, silver/silver chloride reference electrode, and Pt counter electrode downstream of other components. We evaluate a variety of transition metals across the spectrum of ORR activity: palladium, silver, nickel, copper, manganese, and cobalt. Each metal is tested under oxygen and nitrogen saturation in five electrolytes of identical pH: perchloric acid, sulfuric acid, nitric acid, hydrochloric acid, and hydrobromic acid. This setup allows for nearly real time measurement of ORR kinetics and in situ element-specific dissolution rates as a function of time. With careful design of experimental conditions and controlled variables, we are able to suggest mechanisms of degradation with specific reference to conditions under which material loss occurred such as high/low potential, oxygen-saturated/nitrogen-saturated electrolyte, or faradaic/non-faradaic current. We find some metals are stable under nitrogen-saturated electrolyte but corrode more under oxygen-saturated electrolyte only while ORR active. Furthermore, other metals are stable in nitrogen saturated electrolyte at all tested electrochemical conditions but unstable under oxygen saturated electrolyte but only outside the ORR range, implying that cathodic faradaic processes might be stabilizing the surface at low potentials. This stabilization where a thermodynamically unstable material (based on its Pourbaix diagram) exhibits greater immunity while performing ORR in certain electrolytes could inform the development stability mechanisms that direct the design of next generation, non-precious PEMFC cathode catalyst materials. With combined in situ catalyst stability analysis in five pH 1 electrolytes, we can recommend specific conditions for optimizing activity and stability based on the potential range of operation and the electrolyte composition/saturation. We can also distill mechanistic insights from these experiments by creating models that validate causes of catalyst degradation. These models are built using “graphical causal modeling”, which is a mathematical field that goes beyond correlative predictions by venturing into causal inference. We hope to expand this framework into other electrocatalytic reactions of interest. The in-situ ICP-MS electrochemical flow cell setup exhibits promise for accelerating materials stability analysis for enabling next generation Pt-free ORR electrocatalysts through practical experiments and direct comparability to established electrochemical techniques.

Acid Stability and Demetalation of PGM-Free ORR Electrocatalyst Structures from Density Functional Theory: A Model for “Single-Atom Catalyst” Dissolution

Enhancing the Stability of a Pt‐Free ORR Catalyst via Reaction Intermediates

Mechanisms of Stabilization and Degradation of Transition Metal Oxygen Electroreduction Catalysts with in-Situ Electrochemical Flow Cell ICP-MS

Correlative Electrochemical-TEM Study: Probing the Pt Stability of Mesoporous N-Doped Carbon Supported Pt Nanoparticle ORR Electrocatalyst

Optimization of Synthesis Variables Towards Improved Activity and Stability of Fe-N-C PGM-Free Catalysts

On the Stability of an Atomically‐Dispersed Fe−N−C ORR Catalyst: An In Situ XAS Study in a PEMFC

Fe–N–C Electrocatalysts’ Durability: Effects of Single Atoms’ Mobility and Clustering

Operando Fe Dissolution in Fe-N-C Electrocatalysts during Acidic Oxygen Reduction and Impact of Local pH Change

Challenging the Activity-Durability Tradeoff of Fe-N-C Fuel Cell Catalysts via Controlling thermal Activation Atmosphere

(Invited) Progress in Development of Platinum Group Metal-Free Electrocatalysts for Oxygen Reduction Reaction in Polymer Electrolyte Fuel Cells

Atomically Dispersed Dual‐metal‐site PGM‐free Electrocatalysts for Oxygen Reduction Reaction: Opportunities and Challenges

Catalysis Sans Catalyst Loss: The Origins of Prolonged Stability of Graphene-Metal-Graphene Sandwich Architecture for Oxygen Reduction Reactions

The Role of Nitrogen Sources and Hydrogen Adsorption on the Dynamic Stability of Fe-N-C Catalysts in Oxygen Reduction Reaction

Proposing a Model for Platinum Nanoparticles Dissolution in PEM Fuel Cells to Describe Unexplained Electrocatalyst Degradation Consequent to Low Cell Voltage Excursion

PGM-Free Oxygen-Reduction Catalyst Development for Proton-Exchange Membrane Fuel Cells: Challenges, Solutions, and Promises

Ultrastable Fe–N–C Fuel Cell Electrocatalysts by Eliminating Non‐Coordinating Nitrogen and Regulating Coordination Structures at High Temperatures

Operando Fe dissolution in Fe-N-C electrocatalysts during acidic oxygen reduction: impact of local pH change

Durability Assessment of Transition Metal Oxygen Electroreduction Catalysts with on-Line Flow Cell Trace Elemental Analysis

Durable and High-Power Iron-Based Cathodes in Competition with Platinum for Proton-Exchange Membrane Fuel Cells

Platinum Group Metal-Free Oxygen Evolution Electrocatalysts for Alkaline Water Electrolysis

Regulating Catalytic Properties and Thermal Stability of Pt and PtCo Intermetallic Fuel-Cell Catalysts via Strong Coupling Effects between Single-Metal Site-Rich Carbon and Pt