Citizens’ inflated perceptions of the extent of democracy in different African countries: are individuals’ notions of the state an answer to the puzzle?

Hasan Muhammad Baniamin
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s12286-020-00466-1
2020-11-25
Zeitschrift für Vergleichende Politikwissenschaft
Abstract:Based on responses to the Afrobarometer and other surveys, it appears that most Africans believe their country is democratic. Oftentimes they even express satisfaction with the degree of democracy. Experts, however, have shown that many African countries have a flawed democracy or an authoritarian regime. This discrepancy raises questions about trying to measure democracy based on people's perceptions and what these perceptions actually indicate. The current study's analyses (multi-level modelling) based on Afrobarometer (wave 5) indicate that the nature of an individual's orientation towards the state ('rights seeker' vs. 'privilege seeker') can contribute to that individual's belief in the existence of democracy and satisfaction with that perceived democratic governance. This orientation functions as a layer of belief that can affect the cognitive system used to evaluate a political system. When comparing rights seekers' and privilege seekers' responses, the rights seekers are more demanding and have higher standards for personal freedom and political liberty. Consequently, there are variations in the perception of the degree of democracy. Given that the majority of respondents to the Afrobarometer have a privilege seeking nature, this may affect the survey results on questions about democracy. The study explores further mechanisms relating to the possible effects of an individual's orientation towards the state. It finds that privilege seekers tend to believe their country has less corruption and less unequal treatment than rights seekers do. Furthermore, privilege seekers award higher scores on government performance indicators such as 'management of economy' and 'reduction of crime' than do right seekers.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?