“Our Laws Have Not Caught up with the Technology”: Understanding Challenges and Facilitators in Investigating and Prosecuting Child Sexual Abuse Materials in the United States

Olivia Cullen,Keri Zug Ernst,Natalie Dawes,Warren Binford,Gina Dimitropoulos

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/laws9040028

2020-11-26

Laws

Abstract:With technological advances, the creation and distribution of child sexual abuse material (CSAM) has become one of the fastest growing illicit online industries in the United States. Perpetrators are becoming increasingly sophisticated and exploit cutting-edge technology, making it difficult for law enforcement to investigate and prosecute these crimes. There is limited research on best practices for investigating cases of CSAM. The aim of this research was to understand challenges and facilitators for investigating and prosecuting cases of CSAM as a foundation to develop best practices in this area. To meet these objectives, qualitative interviews and focus groups were conducted with participants throughout the western United States. Two major themes arose from this research: Theme 1: Challenges to investigating and prosecuting CSAM; and Theme 2: Facilitators to investigating and prosecuting CSAM. Within Theme 1, subthemes included technology and internet service providers, laws, lack of resources, and service provider mental health and well-being. Within Theme 2, subthemes included multidisciplinary teams and training. This research is a first step in understanding the experiences of law enforcement and prosecutors in addressing CSAM. Findings from this study can be used to support the development of best practices for those in the justice system investigating and prosecuting CSAM.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Based on the provided text content, the main problem that this paper attempts to solve is:

**The mismatch between law and technology**: With the progress of technology, the production and distribution of child sexual abuse material (CSAM) has become one of the fastest - growing illegal online industries in the United States. Offenders are becoming more and more proficient in using cutting - edge technologies, which poses a huge challenge for law enforcement departments in investigating and prosecuting these crimes. Currently, research on best practices for investigating CSAM cases is very limited. Therefore, this study aims to understand the challenges and facilitating factors in investigating and prosecuting CSAM cases, laying the foundation for formulating best practices in this field.

Specifically, the paper explores the following aspects:
1. **Challenges for technology and Internet service providers (ISP)**: The rapid development of technology makes it difficult for law enforcement departments to keep up with offenders. Offenders use various new technologies (such as encryption technology, virtual private networks, peer - to - peer sharing networks, and the dark web) to hide their activities, increasing the difficulty of investigation.
2. **The lag of the law**: The existing legal framework has failed to keep up with the development of technology. Many relevant regulations were formulated in the 1970s and 1980s and are unable to cope with the current technological environment.
3. **Insufficient resources**: Law enforcement agencies lack sufficient resources to effectively deal with a large number of CSAM reports, including human and material resources.
4. **The mental health and well - being of service providers**: Long - term exposure to CSAM materials has a negative impact on the mental health of law enforcement personnel, leading to secondary traumatic stress and job burnout.

Through these discussions, the paper hopes to support law enforcement departments and prosecutors and help them better deal with the investigation and prosecution of CSAM cases.