Investigating the quality of commercially available indigenous southern African plant oils and the need for quality regulation
M.J. Lim Ah Tock,A.M. Viljoen
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.sajb.2024.03.046
IF: 3.111
2024-04-13
South African Journal of Botany
Abstract:South Africa produces a number of indigenous, economically important seed and essential oils. These oils are sold at high prices, which may encourage malpractices such as the adulteration of products, by blending with other less expensive oils, and manipulation of the oil composition of inferior oils by adding specific compounds. Oils produced from wild-harvested plant material, which are typically variable in composition, can influence the batch-to-batch consistency of the oils, both qualitatively and quantitatively. These differences impact on their organoleptic and therapeutic properties. The aim of this study was to investigate the chemical composition of commercially available indigenous fixed oils and essential (volatile) oils, and to compare the levels of characteristic chemical constituents to those reported for authentic oils, to determine the need for compositional guidelines. Selected indigenous seed ( n = 24) and essential oils ( n = 28), purchased from online suppliers, were chemically characterised using gas chromatography coupled with mass spectrometry and flame ionisation detection. The relative concentrations of four major fatty acids, namely palmitic, stearic, oleic and linoleic acids, varied in the seed oils of Adansonia digitata, Sclerocarya birrea, Citrullus lanatus and Schinziophyton rautanenii . However, the ranges mostly correspond to those reported in literature and to that given in available South African National Standards. One sample each of Adansonia digitata and Citrullus lanatus contained considerably different levels of the four major fatty acids and the cyclopropane fatty acid, dihydrosterculic acid, compared to the other samples in the set. Overall, the main compounds for the five commercial essential oil sample sets were found to vary quantitatively mostly, but were strikingly different in some instances. The chemical profile of one Agathosma betulina sample was found to correspond with that of Agathosma crenulata. Artemisia afra samples contained a compound that may be santolinyl acetate at levels of up to 36.0 %, a compound that was not reported in all authentic oils of the same species. Eriocephalus punctulatus samples contained linalyl acetate at up to 11.9 %, but it was absent from authentic oils investigated in a previous study. Citronellyl acetate and phenyl ethyl alcohol were present in the Pelargonium graveolens samples, but were not reported in a previous study of commercial samples. Lippia javanica samples displayed chemotypic variation, which was also reported in a separate study for the species. A minor degree of qualitative variation was observed in some samples for the essential oils, with compounds absent or present. For the first time, the lack of compositional information that can have a direct impact on consumers is highlighted. As the composition directly impacts on the safety, quality and efficacy of these oils, highlighting the need for producers to follow and provide standardised protocols is suggested. A gas chromatographic profile of seed and essential oils, with semi-quantitative percentage areas and reliable identification of the major constituents present, is recommended as a minimum requirement for quality control. Adherence to this guideline can assist to ensure quality, consistency and authenticity of seed and essential oil products produced and marketed in South Africa. Quality control measures, and where possible, material standardisation, is of paramount importance. The standardisation of preselected plant materials used for essential oil production through cloning and cultivation are key to ensuring chemical consistency and consumer safety.
plant sciences