Severity of COVID-19 and survival in patients with rheumatic and inflammatory diseases: data from the French RMD COVID-19 cohort of 694 patients

Florence Aeschlimann,Nassim Ait-Abdallah,Jean-David Albert,Didier Alcais,Yannick Allanore,Blanca Amador-Borreiro,Zahir Amoura,Emma Andre,Jean-Benoît Arlet,Laurent Arnaud,Denis Arniaud,Herliette Arty-Hue,Lucie Atlan,Christine Audoin-Pajot,Victor Audren,Jérôme Avouac,Maxime Bach-Bunner,Hélène Bacquet-Deschryver,Brigitte Bader-Meunier,Nathalie Balandraud,Jean-Charles Balblanc,Stéphane Bally,Frédéric Banal,Béatrice Banneville,Thomas Barnetche,Audre Barrelet,André Basch,Vincent Baumier,Guillaume Bayer,Sophie Bayle,Véronique Belin,Rakiba Belkhir,Ruben Benainous,Alexandre Belot,Mohammed Benammar,Mathilde Benhamou,Ygal Benhamou,Ahmed Benmansour,Pascal Bennet,Brigitte Bernoux-Manat,Emilie Berthoux,Ewa Bertolini,Aurélia Bisson-Vaivre,Gilles Blaison,Gilles Bolla,Olivier Bonidan,Christine Bonnet,Raphaël Borie,Laurence Boudou,Françoise Bouhour,Kévin Bouiller,Bastien Bouldoires,Karima Boussoualim,Eric Bouvard,Regine Brondino,Pierre Buchlin,Patrice Cacoub,Maurizio Carteni,Aurélia Carbasse,Brice Castel,Pascal Cathebras,Hervé Caumont,Annalisa Celant,Benjamin Chaigne,Benoît Chaillous,Romuald Champy,Agnès Charcot,Pierre Charles,Isabelle Charlot-Lambrecht,Caroline Charpin,Emmanuel Chatelus,Bernard Chaudier,Pascal Chazerain,Pascale Chertok,Xavier Chevalier,Maxime Chevreau,Emilie Chotard,Lin Chu Miow,Pascal Claudepierre,Gaëlle Clavel,Cyril Clavel-Osorio,Fleur Cohen,Gregory Cohen,Marie-Eve Colette-Cedoz,Nived Collercandy,Antoine Colombey,Chloé Comarmond,Bernard Combe,Céline Comparon,Elodie Constant,Corre Clémence,Nathalie Costedoat-Chalumeau,Marie Couret,Natacha Courvoisier,Fabienne Coury-Lucas,Cécile Coutarel,Fabrice Coutier,Richard Damade,Laurence Daver-Malaterre,Sarahe Dehimat,Michel Delahousse,Elise Descamps,Chantal Deslandre,Marie Desmurs,Jacques Despaux,Marie Desplats,Frédérick Detree,Valérie Devauchelle-Pensec,Mathilde Devaux,Robin Dhote,Philippe Dieude,Yannick Dieudonne,Elisabeth Diot,Guillaume Direz,Djamal-Dine Djeddi,Fanny Domont,Béatrice Drouet,Elodie Drumez,Catherine Duc,Angélique Ducornet,Carine Dufauret-Lombard,Alain Duhamel,Cécile Dumaine,Anne-Elisabeth Dumel,Géraldine Durand,Pierre-Marie Duret,Mikaël Ebbo,Esther Ebstein,Andra Economu-Dubosc,Soumaya El Mahou,Romain Euvrard,Philippe Evon,Sylvie Fabre,Marion Fauconier,Bruno Fautrel,Jacques Fechtenbaum,Renaud Felten,Fanny Fernandes,Nicole Ferreira-Maldent,Elodie Feurer,Amandine Fichet,Françoise Flaisler,René-Marc Flipo,Nans Florens,Violaine Foltz,Elisabeth Fontanges,Jennifer Foret,Anne-Claire Fougerousse,Anne Fouque-Aubert,Catherine Foutrier-Morello,Hélène Francois-Pradier,Léa Frantzen,Pierre Fritz,Antoine Froissart,Jean Fulpin,Piera Fuzibet,Francis Gaches,Laurence Gagneux-Lemoussu,Penhoat Mélanie Gahier,Joris Galland,Frédérique Gandjbakhch,Nicole Garnier,Thomas Garraud,Jean-François Garrot,Romain Gastaldi,Véronique Gaud-Listrat,Maud Gauthier-Prieur,Dana Georgescu,Sophie Georgin-Lavialle,Nathalie Gerard,Elisabeth Gervais,Christelle Gibert,Eric Gibert,Ghislaine Gill,Jérôme Gillard,Mélanie Gilson,Pauline Grenoble Gimonnet,Jeanine-Sophie Giraudet-Le Quintrec,Aude Giraud-Morelet,Baptiste Glace,Camille Glanowski,Bertrand Godeau,Bruno Gombert,Camille Gonnet-Gracia,Tiphaine Goulenok,Philippe Goupille,Olivier Gourmelen,Sophie Govindaraju-Audouard,Franck Grados,Bruno Grardel,Anne Grasland,Gilles Grateau,Monica Groza,Constance Guillaud,Séverine Guillaume,Xavier Guillot,Philippe Guilpain,Aline Gury,Marie-Hélène Guyot,Eric Hachulla,Cécile Hacquard-Bouder,Marie-Noelle Havard,Jean-Pierre Hellier,Pascal Hennequin,Basile Henriot,Julien Henry,Véronique Hentgen,Marion Hermet,Muriel Herasse,Miguel Hie,Ambre Hittinger-Roux,Christophe Hudry,Serge Huguenel,Clara Jaccard,Jean-Michel Jacquemier,Bénédicte Jamard,Catherine Jan,Sylvie Jean,Mathieu Jouvray,Pierre-Antoine Juge,Laurent Juillard,Denis Jullien,Anna Kabala,Abdelkrim Kabchou,Ludovic Karkowski,Françoise Karman,Farid Kemiche,Jérémy Keraen,Isabelle Kone-Paut,Abdeldajallil Koreichi,Sylvain La Batide Alanore,Pierre Lafforgue,Sophie Lahalle,Vincent Langlois,Sylvain Lanot,Aurélia Lanteri,Jean-Paul Larbre,Augustin Latourte,Sophie Le Guen Guegan,Guillaume Le Guenno,Agnès Lebrun,Emmanuel Ledoult,Nathalie Legoupil,Erick Legrand,Charlotte Lejeune,Olivier Leloire,Christophe Leroux,Rémi Leroy,Tifenn Leturcq,Frédéric Liote,Anne Lohse,Virginie Lucas,Aurélie Madelon,Matthieu Mahevas,Hélène Maillard,Thibault Maillet,Sandrine Malochet-Guinamand,Quentin Mangon,Sylvie Marchou-Lopez,Nathalie Margarit,Thierry Marhadour,Alexandre Maria,Xavier Mariette,Hubert Marotte,Alexis Mathian,François Maurier,Frédéric Maury,Betty Mazet-Guillaume,Angers Mazouyez Arnaud,Hassan Contamine-Sur-Arve Mazyad,Nadia Mehsen-Cetre,Ulrich Meinzer,Arsène Mekinian,Isabelle Melki,Laurent Messer,Martin Michaud,Mathilde Michon,Anne-Marie Milesi-Lecat,Anna Molto,Marie Moly,Olivier Moranne,Gautier Morel,Hugo Morel,Jacques Morel,Franck Morin,Laurence Moulinier,Guillaume Moulis,Bertrand Moura,Minh Nguyen,Sabine Nicolas-Vullierme,Hubert Nielly,Gaétane Nocturne,Henri-Olivier Ollagnon,Isabelle Pacaud-Vitoux,Caroline Charpin,Antoine Parrot,Tristan Pascart,Yasmina Pascaud-Mansour,Lætitia Paulin,Stephan Pavy,Laurent Perard,Yves-Marie Pers,Edouard Pertuiset,Micheline Pha,Thao Pham,Maud Pichon,Gabrielle Argenteuil Pizana,Elsa Poix,Agnès Portier,Jacques Pouchot,Antoine Poulet,Samira Plassard,Grégory Pugnet,Déborah Puyraimond-Zemmour,Pierre Quartier-Dit-Maire,Marion Quenet,Philippe Remy,Myriam Renard,Jessica Rene,Sabine Revuz,Gaëlle Richard-Colmant,Christophe Richez,Etienne Riviere,Sébastien Riviere,Sophie Robin,Julien Rohmer,Isabelle Roitg,Mélanie Romier,Michel Rolland,Mélanie Roriz,Linda Rossi,Olivier Roth,Sid-Ahmed Rouidi,Mathilde Roumier,Mickaël Rousiere,Clémentine Rousselin,Christian Roux,Fabienne Roux,Marielle Roux,Nicolas Roux,Diane Rouzaud,Sylvie Rozenberg,Isabelle Sacco,Fatiha Sadji,Laurent Sailler,Carine Salliot,Jean-Hugues Salmon,Jean Schmidt,Julie Seguier,Jérémie Sellam,Eric Senbel,Thomas Sene,Patricia Senet,Raphaële Seror,Amélie Servettaz,Pascal Seve,Aurélie Sicaud,Perrine Smets,Vincent Sobanski,Christelle Sordet,Elisabeth Sornay-Rendu,Odile Souchaud-Debouverie,Lætitia Sparsa,Sarah Steib,Victor Strotz,Paulina Szafors,Séverine Taffignon-Clave,Justine Simoens,Nora Tenenbaum,Benoît Thomachot,Thierry Thomas,Nathalie Tieulie,Alice Tison,Eric Toussirot,Ludovic Trefond,Sophie Trijau,Sébastien Trouillier,Marie-Elise Truchetet,Eric Veillard,Laurent Veillon,Guillaume Vial,Laurent Veillon,Guillaume Vial,Jean-François Viallard,Judith Victor,Claire Vidon,Mathias Vidon,Camille Vigne,Alexandre Virone,Ursula Warzocha,Daniel Wendling,Claude Werle,Alexandra Willems,Michel Wisniewski,Juliette Woessner,Bernadette Xerri-Campano

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/annrheumdis-2020-218310

IF: 27.973

2020-12-02

Annals of the Rheumatic Diseases

Abstract:Objectives There is little known about the impact of SARS-CoV-2 on patients with inflammatory rheumatic and musculoskeletal diseases (iRMD). We examined epidemiological characteristics associated with severe disease, then with death. We also compared mortality between patients hospitalised for COVID-19 with and without iRMD. Methods Individuals with suspected iRMD-COVID-19 were included in this French cohort. Logistic regression models adjusted for age and sex were used to estimate adjusted ORs and 95% CIs of severe COVID-19. The most significant clinically relevant factors were analysed by multivariable penalised logistic regression models, using a forward selection method. The death rate of hospitalised patients with iRMD-COVID-19 (moderate–severe) was compared with a subset of patients with non-iRMD-COVID-19 from a French hospital matched for age, sex, and comorbidities. Results Of 694 adults, 438 (63%) developed mild (not hospitalised), 169 (24%) moderate (hospitalised out of the intensive care unit (ICU) and 87 (13%) severe (patients in ICU/deceased) disease. In multivariable imputed analyses, the variables associated with severe infection were age (OR=1.08, 95% CI: 1.05–1.10), female gender (OR=0.45, 95% CI: 0.25–0.80), body mass index (OR=1.07, 95% CI: 1.02–1.12), hypertension (OR=1.86, 95% CI: 1.01–3.42), and use of corticosteroids (OR=1.97, 95% CI: 1.09–3.54), mycophenolate mofetil (OR=6.6, 95% CI: 1.47–29.62) and rituximab (OR=4.21, 95% CI: 1.61–10.98). Fifty-eight patients died (8% (total) and 23% (hospitalised)). Compared with 175 matched hospitalised patients with non-iRMD-COVID-19, the OR of mortality associated with hospitalised patients with iRMD-COVID-19 was 1.45 (95% CI: 0.87–2.42) (n=175 each group). Conclusions In the French RMD COVID-19 cohort, as already identified in the general population, older age, male gender, obesity, and hypertension were found to be associated with severe COVID-19. Patients with iRMD on corticosteroids, but not methotrexate, or tumour necrosis factor alpha and interleukin-6 inhibitors, should be considered as more likely to develop severe COVID-19. Unlike common comorbidities such as obesity, and cardiovascular or lung diseases, the risk of death is not significantly increased in patients with iRMD. Trial registration number ClinicalTrials.gov Registry ( NCT04353609 ).

rheumatology