Treatment of Early Stage Tonsil Cancer in the Age of Human Papillomavirus–Associated Malignancies

Evan J. Patel,Angela W. Zhu,Jamie R. Oliver,MacIntosh Cornwell,Adam S. Jacobson,Kenneth S. Hu,Moses Tam,Alec Vaezi,Luc G. T. Morris,Babak Givi
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/0194599820973256
2020-12-08
Otolaryngology–Head and Neck Surgery
Abstract:Objective To investigate the patterns of care and outcomes of treatment of early stage tonsil cancers, controlling for human papillomavirus (HPV) status. Study Design Historical cohort study. Setting National Cancer Database (NCDB). Methods Review of the NCDB between 2010 and 2017 for all T1-2N0M0 tonsillar squamous cell carcinoma (SCC). Demographics, clinical characteristics, HPV status, treatment regimens, and survival were analyzed. Results A total of 4720 patients were identified with early stage SCC of the tonsil. Most were tested for HPV (2759 [58.5%]). Among tested patients, 1758 (63.7%) were positive for HPV and 1001 (36.3%) were negative for HPV. HPV-positive patients had higher 3-year survival compared to HPV-negative patients (93.2% vs 77.8%, P < .001). Among HPV-positive patients, there was no significant difference in survival between treatment cohorts. However, in the HPV-negative cohort, 3-year survival was higher in both bimodality surgical-based settings (tonsillectomy + neck dissection + radiotherapy, 86.0% vs chemoradiotherapy, 69.6%, P = .01) and for all surgical-based treatments when compared to nonsurgical management (84.6% vs 69.3%, P < .001). This difference was maintained in multivariable regression controlling for age, sex, comorbidities, clinical T stage, and treatments. In a subpopulation of HPV-negative patients propensity score matched by all factors significant in multivariable analysis, 3-year survival remained higher in the surgically treated group compared to the nonsurgically treated cohort (84.9% vs 67.1%, P < .001). Conclusions Surgical- or radiation-based treatment resulted in similar survival in early stage HPV-positive tonsil cancer. Surgical-based treatments were associated with longer survival in HPV-negative cancers. These findings should be further investigated in a randomized prospective trial.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?