Abstract:Traditional methodologies for measuring visual distraction have been limiting in their approaches, treating distraction as a one-dimensional variable. This has been accomplished either by categorizing distraction as a binary variable or using surrogate measurements, such as reaction time in response to non-driving related tasks, which follow the procedures of measuring distraction from psychology. Furthermore, as human-vehicle interaction (HVI) under automated driving has the potential to provide safety information and bring visual distraction simultaneously, there lacks an investigation on the quantitative relationship between distraction and safety due to the restrained methodologies in measuring visual distraction. As HVI-induced driver distraction plays a critical role in determining safe driving under automated driving, a methodology is highly needed to comprehensively measure the visual distraction under automated driving so that its impact on safety can be further investigated. Therefore, sticking to the definition of visual distraction, this research aims to (1) improve the existing methodology in measuring HVI-induced driver distraction under automated driving by focusing on visual distraction and mathematically describing it from spatiotemporal and directional dimensions; (2) theoretically investigate how the quantified visual distraction influences driving safety and (3) quantify the relationship between distraction and safety with introducing the "distraction-safety" ratio. Drivers' fixation behaviors are used in quantifying visual distraction, which is measured by spatiotemporal and directional relationships between drivers' visual attention and the attention that indicates "zero distraction". Three newly added performance measures in quantifying HVI-induced visual distraction are real-time magnitudes, real-time directions, and intensities (cumulation of magnitudes over time). To validate the proposed methods, a verification study was conducted by recruiting drivers to test automated driving under Level 3 automation. Drivers are required to wear an eye-tracker and go through two scenarios interacting with jaywalkers where takeover actions are needed with two takeover warnings ("visual-only" and "visual & audible"). Per past studies, takeover time was measured in representing distraction level. As a result, this study confirms the validity of the proposed methods by revealing the significant and positive correlations between the measured distraction intensity and the takeover time. Discussions of the quantified visual distraction from the spatiotemporal and directional perspective further enhance the understanding of HVI-induced driver distraction under automated driving through multiple dimensions. Furthermore, this research reveals how distracted driving affects safety under automated driving through the takeover performance. Thresholds under visual distraction magnitudes and degrees that lead to traffic conflicts were identified. More importantly, a "distraction-safety" ratio that quantifies the relationship between visual distraction and safety benefits is proposed. The results suggest that the "visual & audible" is more effective in significantly enhancing safety while aggregating a significantly smaller amount of visual distraction. The contribution of this research is to re-define the methodological approach of measuring visual distraction by (1) measuring distraction multi-dimensionally and (2) establishing a "distraction-safety" system in quantitatively assessing the balance of safety benefits and the HVI-induced visual distraction magnitude under automated driving environment.

Impact of HMI on driver’s distraction on a freeway under heavy foggy condition based on visual characteristics

Method of HMI Optimization Design Based on Fixation Transition Characteristics and Visual Attention Trajectory: A Driver Simulator Study

Investigating the impact of HMI on drivers' merging performance in intelligent connected vehicle environment

Transitioning to multi-dimensional estimation of visual distraction and its safety effects under automated driving: A spatiotemporal and directional estimation approach

A study of the compliance level of connected vehicle warning information in a fog warning system based on a driving simulation

Impacts of information quantity and display formats on driving behaviors in a connected vehicle environment

Adopting an HMI for overtaking assistance - Impact of distance display, advice, and guidance information on driver gaze and performance

Effects of Various In-Vehicle Human-Machine Interfaces on Drivers' Takeover Performance and Gaze Pattern in Conditionally Automated Vehicles

Research on the Effects of in-Vehicle Human-Machine Interface on Drivers' Pre and Post Takeover Request Eye-tracking Characteristics

Study on the Influence of Connected Vehicle Fog Warning Systems on Driving Behavior and Safety

Evaluation of fog warning system on driving under heavy fog condition based on driving simulator

How does AR-HUD system affect driving behaviour Evidence from an eye-tracking experiment study

Improving Pedestrian Safety with Head-Up Display Warning in a Connected Environment

Effects of full windshield head-up display on visual attention allocation

The effects of using taxi-hailing application on driving performance

The impact of AR-HUD intelligent driving on the allocation of cognitive resources under the breakthrough of 5G technology

Study on drivers' visual perception characteristics during the take‐over of vehicle control in automated driving

Effectiveness Assessment of Human-Machine Interface in Driver Assistance System

Effects of Head-Up Display Information Layout Design on Driver Performance: Driving Simulator Studies

Investigating HMIs to Foster Communications between Conventional Vehicles and Autonomous Vehicles in Intersections

Effects of using head-up display in automobile context on attention demand and driving performance