Ten Years of ‘Flying the Flag’: An Overview and Retrospective Consideration of the Active School Flag Physical Activity Initiative for Children—Design, Development & Evaluation

Sarahjane Belton,Úna Britton,Elaine Murtagh,Sarah Meegan,Christina Duff,Jamie McGann
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/children7120300
2020-12-16
Children
Abstract:Whole-school physical activity (PA) promotion programmes are recommended to increase youth PA. Evaluation of programmes is essential to ensure practice is guided by evidence. This paper evaluates the Active School Flag (ASF), a whole-school PA promotion programme in Ireland, using the Reach, Effectiveness, Adoption, Implementation, and Maintenance (RE-AIM) framework. ASF was evaluated across three levels—(1) administration, (2) application, (3) outcomes—using a mixed-methods case study design. Existing data sources were reviewed, the programme coordinator was interviewed, and a pilot study was conducted to investigate impact on 3rd and 5th class students (3 schools, n = 126 students, age range 8–12 years). In-school Moderate to Vigorous Physical Activity (MVPA; by accelerometery), motivation for PA (BREQ), PA self-efficacy (PASES), school affect and peer social support (Kidscreen27) were measured pre-programme (0 months), post-programme (8 months), and at retention (12 months). Teacher perceptions of classroom behaviour (CBAST) were also measured pre- and post-programme. ASF has been successful in engaging 46% of primary schools nationally. Students’ in-school moderate–vigorous PA increased in all pilot-study schools from pre-programme to retention (η2 = 0.68–0.84). ASF programme design facilitates implementation fidelity, adoption and maintenance through buy in from schools and government stakeholders. ASF presents as an effective PA promotion programme in the short-to-medium term for primary schools. This RE-AIM evaluation provides evidence of ASF effectiveness, alongside valuable findings that could support programme improvement, and inform future similar programmes.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper attempts to address the issue of evaluating the impact and effectiveness of Ireland's "Active School Flag" (ASF) program in promoting physical activity among children. Specifically, the study assesses the design, development, and outcomes of the ASF program through the RE-AIM framework (i.e., Reach, Effectiveness, Adoption, Implementation, and Maintenance). The main objectives of the study are: 1. **Evaluate Reach**: Understand how many schools nationwide have adopted the ASF program. 2. **Evaluate Effectiveness**: Examine whether there is a significant increase in moderate-to-vigorous physical activity (MVPA) among students in schools participating in the ASF program. 3. **Evaluate Adoption**: Analyze how many schools are willing to adopt and implement the ASF program. 4. **Evaluate Implementation**: Check the fidelity and consistency of schools in implementing the ASF program. 5. **Evaluate Maintenance**: Explore whether schools can sustain their positive physical activity environment after obtaining the ASF flag. Through these evaluations, the study aims to provide valuable references and improvement suggestions for future similar projects.