Abstract:Background: The proposal of Q-markers for traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) represents a novel avenue of research pertaining to the quality control of TCM prescriptions. However, prior exploratory studies on Q-markers with multiple properties consistently neglected the consideration of weights, hampering our ability to accurately gauge the significance of each property and potentially leading to a flawed comprehension of Q-markers. Purpose: In this study, a quantitative ternary network strategy was firstly proposed to visually discover the Q-markers from TCM prescriptions, and it has been successfully applied into the quality control study of Bu-Zhong-Yi-Qi-Tang (BZYQT), a classical TCM prescription. Methods: Firstly, the contents of 34 components in BZYQT, along with the kinetic features of 17 candidate Q-markers in biosamples (plasma and small intestinal contents), were characterized by UPLC-QqQ-MS/MS, and their immunomodulatory activities in macrophages and splenic lymphocytes were also assessed. Next, the obtained data were integrated into three properties: testability, bioavailability, effectiveness, and their weights were calculated using the entropy weight method to further establish a ternary network for quantitatively screening Q-markers. Subsequently, the identified Q-markers of BZYQT were utilized for the holistic quality evaluation of 36 batches of the commercial BZYQT preparation, Bu-Zhong-Yi-Qi-Pill (BZYQP) produced by three manufacturers, through similarity evaluation of the Q-marker-based fingerprint. Results: Nine compounds (hesperidin, astragaloside IV, ononin, 18β-glycyrrhizic acid, narirutin, calycosin, cimigenoside, astragaloside II, and liquiritin) showing three core properties, including testability, bioavailability, and effectiveness, were screened out as Q-markers of BZYQT based on their rankings in terms of regression area of the ternary network. Employing Q-markers as common peaks, the similarity values of 36 batches BZYQP ranged 0.914-0.998 under HPLC-UVD mode, and 0.631-1.000 under HPLC-ELSD mode, which were less than the similarity values evaluated by the conventional common peaks (HPLC-UVD mode: 0.946-0.990; HPLC-ELSD mode: 0.957-0.997). This observation suggests that the identified Q-markers are more representative as common peaks in chromatographic fingerprints for the holistic quality evaluation of TCM-related products from different manufacturers. Conclusion: The quantitative discovery of Q-markers from BZYQT laid an important foundation for holistic quality assessment of its related commercially available products, and our work offering a new strategy for ensuring the consistency and efficacy of TCM prescriptions.

Combined Quantitative Analysis of Multi-Markers Assay by Monolinear Method with Two-Dimensional Antioxidant Profiles, Establishing a Trinity Fingerprint Evaluation System of Tcm

Direct Analysis in Real Time Mass Spectrometry and Multivariate Data Analysis: a Novel Approach to Rapid Identification of Analytical Markers for Quality Control of Traditional Chinese Medicine Preparation.

A strategy takes "Yiqing" tablets as an example to carry out simpler multi-component quantification and use fingerprint technology for comprehensive quality consistency evaluation

Establishing the chromatographic fingerprint of traditional Chinese medicine standard decoction based on quality by design approach: A case study of Licorice.

Quality assessment of liquorice combined with quantum fingerprint profiles and electrochemical activity

Development of a method using high-performance liquid chromatographic fingerprint and multi-ingredients quantitative analysis for the quality control of Yangxinshi Pian.

A new method to comprehensively evaluate the quality of Tianma Toutong tablets by multiple fingerprints combined with quantitative analysis and prescription analysis.

Development of a novel method combining HPLC fingerprint and multi-ingredients quantitative analysis for quality evaluation of traditional Chinese medicine preparation.

Quality evaluation of moluodan concentrated pill using high-performance liquid chromatography fingerprinting coupled with chemometrics.

An Ultra-Robust Fingerprinting Method for Quality Assessment of Traditional Chinese Medicine Using Multiple Reaction Monitoring Mass Spectrometry.

Application of fingerprint combined with quantitative analysis and multivariate chemometric methods in quality evaluation of dandelion ( Taraxacum mongolicum )

A rapid evaluation method for the quality consistency assessment and spectrum-effect relationship study of Xiaohuoluo Pills developed based on the spectral and chromatography combined technology

Holistically assessing the quality consistency of compound liquorice tablets from similarities of both all chemical fingerprints and the integrated dissolution curves by systematically quantified fingerprint method

Integration of fingerprint-activity relationship and chemometric analysis to accurately screen Q-markers for the quality control of traditional Chinese medicine compound preparation: Jinlian Qingre granules as an example

Quality evaluation of natural monomer flavors for Chinese tobacco industry based on dual mode combined Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance mass spectrometry and isotopic fine structures

Chromatographic Fingerprinting Based on Column Switching Technology for Quality Evaluation of Tianmeng Oral Liquid

An Integrated Exact Mass Spectrometric Strategy for Comprehensive and Rapid Characterization of Phenolic Compounds in Licorice

A study for quality evaluation of Taxilli Herba from different hosts based on fingerprint-activity relationship modeling and multivariate statistical analysis

Comprehensive quality evaluation of Lysimachia christinae Hance via fingerprint, spectrum–effect relationship, and quantitative analyses of multiple components by single marker

Comprehensive evaluation of NAODESHENG by combining UPLC quantitative fingerprint and antioxidant activity

Quantitative ternary network-oriented discovery of Q-markers from traditional Chinese medicine prescriptions: Bu-Zhong-Yi-Qi-Tang as a case study