Abstract:Movies often use allusions to add depth, create connections, and enrich the storytelling. However, translators may face challenges when subtitling movie allusions, as they must render both meaning and culture accurately despite existing language and cultural barriers. These challenges could be further complicated by the use of available AI tools attempting to subtitle movie allusions, while probably unaware of existing cultural complexities. This research investigates these challenges using qualitative and descriptive quantitative approaches by analyzing the movie Birdman or (The Unexpected Virtue of Ignorance) , comprising13.014 words, to identify the types of allusions used and compare the human- vs. AI (ChatGPT)-generated Arabic subtitles in terms of the subtitling strategies, their frequency, and quality. The results revealed that the movie used 52 Noun Phrase (NP) allusions, where the writer intertextually employed a proper name to convey meaning, and 8 Key-Phrase (KP) allusions, where the writer used phrases that convey implicit meaning easily perceived by members of the source culture (by referring to religious, literary, or entertainment texts). For NP allusions, both the human translator and AI opted for retentive strategies; however, the human translator's preference to add guidance/parentheses to mark NP allusions was distinct. Additionally, it was observed that AI used neologism to render technology-related allusions, which could be a suggested strategy for NP subtitling into Arabic. For KP allusions, while the human translator seemed to be cognizant of the idea that KP allusions typically require a change in wording, AI fell short. Specifically, the human translator employed reduction in 5 out of 8 KPs, opting for minimum change/literal translation only three times. Conversely, AI utilized literal translation in all 8 examples, despite its awareness of the allusion and its intricate meaning/reference. As for the FAR assessment, for NP allusions, it revealed minor semantic errors in AI's subtitles that did not affect the plot. Regarding KP allusions, AI's subtitles were penalized in 5 out of its 8 Arabic renditions, in contrast to the human translator. Most of the errors were serious semantic errors that likely disrupted the flow of reading the subtitles due to conveying irrelevant meanings in the movie's/scene's context. Despite its functionality, this study suggests adding an extra parameter to the FAR model: consistency, as it plays a role in enhancing audience involvement and understanding. Its absence, as observed in some AI instances, can be misleading.

Integrating Vermeer’s Skopos Theory into Newmark’s Strategies for Exploring Cultural Problems in Subtitles: A Case Study of the American series Thirteen Reasons Why

Translating and Subtitling Cultural-Bound Expressions Based on Friends Series into Arabic

Problems in Subtitling Cultural-Bound Expressions in “Theeb” Movie: A Case Study

An Analysis of Subtitle Translation of Mulan: Skopos Theory-Inspired Perspective

The analysis and quality assessment of translation strategies in subtitling culturally specific references: Feathers

Translating Cultural Features in Arabic Subtitles of English Literary Film Adaptations between Domestication and Foreignization

Subtitling Taboo Expressions from a Conservative to a More Liberal Culture

Subtitling Strategies of Swear Words and Taboo Expressions from English into Arabic in the American Sitcom Friends: Corpus-Based Study

The Americanization of Film Subtitles: A Sociocultural Linguistic Perspective to Subtitling Translation in the Arab World

Strategies Subtitlers Use in Rendering English Slang Expressions Into Arabic

On Subtitle Translation of American TV Series from the Perspective of Functional Equivalence Theory

Netflix English Subtitling of the Jordanian Movie 'The Alleys': Challenges and Strategies

The Transfer of Culture-Specific Items in Subtitling

A Comparative Study on English and Persian Subtitles of Korean Slangs: A Case of Television Variety Show Running Man

Audio visual translation: An evaluation of English-Turkish subtitles of “Orange Is the New Black” in terms of Toury’s initial norms and translation strategies

Strategies of translating swear words into Arabic: a case study of a parallel corpus of Netflix English-Arabic movie subtitles

Subtitling of Jordanian Culture-Specific Expressions in “The Alley” Movie

Subtitling of culture-bound terms: strategies and quality assessment

Arabic Audio-Visual Translation Censorship: A Corpus Study of Subtitles of Three Films

Exploring challenges in audiovisual translation: A comparative analysis of human- and AI-generated Arabic subtitles in Birdman

Subtitling Research in the Arab World: Review Article