Abstract:The effect of media multitasking ( e.g., listening to podcasts while studying) on cognitive processes has seen mixed results thus far. To date, the tasks used in the literature to study this phenomenon have been classical paradigms primarily used to examine processes such as working memory. While perfectly valid on their own, these paradigms do not approximate a real-world volitional multitasking environment. To remedy this, as well as attempt to further validate previously found effects in the literature, we designed a novel experimental framework that mimics a desktop computer environment where a “popup” associated with a secondary task would occasionally appear. Participants could choose to attend to the popup, or to ignore it. Attending to the popup would prompt a word stem completion task, while ignoring it would continue the primary math problem verification task. We predicted that individuals who are more impulsive, more frequent media multitaskers, and individuals who prefer to multitask (quantified with the Barratt Impulsiveness Scale, a modified version of the Media Use Questionnaire, and the Multitasking Preference Inventory) would be more distracted by popups, choose to switch tasks more often and more quickly, and be slower to return to the primary task compared to those who media multitask to a lesser degree. We found that as individuals media multitask to a greater extent, they are slower to return to the previous (primary) task set and are slower to complete the primary task overall whether a popup was present or not, among other task performance measures. We found a similar pattern of effects within individuals who prefer to multitask. Our findings suggest that overall, more frequent media multitaskers show a marginal decrease in task performance, as do preferential multitaskers. Attentional impulsivity was not found to influence any task performance measures, but was positively related to a preference for multitasking. While our findings may lack generalizability due to the modifications to the Media Use Questionnaire, and this initial study is statically underpowered, this paradigm is a crucial first step in establishing a more ecologically valid method to study real-world multitasking.

Boredom and Media Multitasking

Do Rising Opportunity Costs Lead to Increases in Media Multitasking Over Time?

Media multitasking is linked to attentional errors, mind wandering and automatised response to stimuli without full conscious processing

Fast-forward to boredom: How switching behavior on digital media makes people more bored.

Media Multitasking and Well-Being of University Students

Media Multitasking Negatively Impacts Cognitive Flexibility

Keeping Up with Media Multitasking: An Eye-Tracking Study among Children and Adults to Investigate the Impact of Media Multitasking Behavior on Switching Frequency, Advertising Attention, and Advertising Effectiveness

A desire for distraction: uncovering the rates of media multitasking during online research studies

Effects of media multitasking frequency on a novel volitional multitasking paradigm

Media multitasking and memory: Differences in working memory and long-term memory

Individual differences in media multitasking and performance on the n-back

Media Multitasking Scores and Media Use Hours: A Comparison Across the Standard Stroop Task and an Emotional Stroop Task

Why Do We Need Media Multitasking? A Self-Regulatory Perspective

The Media Psychology of Boredom and Mobile Media Use: Theoretical and Methodological Innovations

Watching the Clock: Boredom and Vigilance Performance

HPA activity mediates the link between trait impulsivity and boredom

The "Me" in Media Multitasking: The Role of Temperament, Media Use Motivations and Executive Functioning in Adolescent Media Multitasking

Completing a Sustained Attention Task Is Associated With Decreased Distractibility and Increased Task Performance Among Adolescents With Low Levels of Media Multitasking

Active vs passive media multitasking and memory for lecture materials

Media Multitasking: Performance Differences Between Younger and Older Adults and the Role of Working Memory

Distracted mind: the effects of multitasking and mind wandering on consumer memory for ad content