A scoping review of global patterns in reporting race, ethnicity, nationality, or religion in palliative care randomized controlled trials: Recommendations for transparency
Gary Witham,Natalie G Regier,Martha Abshire Saylor,Sarah Allgood,Samantha Curriero,Tamryn F Gray,Elifnur Gunes,Bryan R Hansen,Reena Levy,Katie E Nelson,Claire M Petchler,Rebecca Singer Cohen,Rebecca Wright
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/02692163241291352
IF: 5.7133
2024-11-21
Palliative Medicine
Abstract:Palliative Medicine, Ahead of Print. Background:Though randomized controlled trials of non-pharmacological palliative care interventions have shown positive outcomes, findings are often generalized with limited consideration for the impact of the influence of race, ethnicity, nationality, or religion on said outcomes.Aim:To identify trends and gaps in global reporting of racial, ethnic, nationality, and religious demographics in non-pharmacological palliative care randomized controlled trials.Design:We conducted a scoping review guided by the Joanna Briggs methodology,Data sources:Global randomized controlled trials published in English, between 1999 and 2021 extracted from databases: Cochrane, PubMed, and Scopus. Inclusion criteria were non-pharmacological palliative care interventions for people with serious conditions reporting on one or more of the demographics of race, ethnicity, nationality, or religion.Results:Our review included 131 (44%) articles published from 19 countries, predominantly the USA (n = 84, 64%). Most studies focused on cancer (n = 71, 54%) in inpatient settings (n = 85, 64%). Race was the most commonly reported demographic (n = 93, 70%), followed by ethnicity (n = 54, 41%), religion (n = 46, 35%), nationality (n = 20, 15%). Within racial reporting, 86 (92%) indicating a majority White/Caucasian sample. Only 14 (10%) articles provided context connecting participant demographics to intervention outcomes. Demographic data was discussed only as a limitation to generalizability in 18 cases (41%).Conclusions:Improving greater transparency in study reporting of social and historical context about population demographics, including specific demographic data collected, may better identify unmet palliative needs, facilitate cross-cultural interpretation, and improve adaptation and implementation of non-pharmacological palliative care interventions.
medicine, general & internal,public, environmental & occupational health,health care sciences & services