Topological data analysis reveals genotype–phenotype relationships in primary ciliary dyskinesia

Amelia Shoemark,Bruna Rubbo,Marie Legendre,Mahmoud R. Fassad,Eric G. Haarman,Sunayna Best,Irma C.M. Bon,Joost Brandsma,Pierre-Regis Burgel,Gunnar Carlsson,Siobhan B. Carr,Mary Carroll,Matt Edwards,Estelle Escudier,Isabelle Honoré,David Hunt,Gregory Jouvion,Michel R. Loebinger,Bernard Maitre,Deborah Morris-Rosendahl,Jean-Francois Papon,Camille M. Parsons,Mitali P. Patel,N. Simon Thomas,Guillaume Thouvenin,Woolf T. Walker,Robert Wilson,Claire Hogg,Hannah M. Mitchison,Jane S. Lucas

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1183/13993003.02359-2020

IF: 24.3

2021-01-21

European Respiratory Journal

Abstract:Background Primary ciliary dyskinesia (PCD) is a heterogeneous inherited disorder caused by mutations in approximately 50 cilia-related genes. PCD genotype–phenotype relationships have mostly arisen from small case series because existing statistical approaches to investigating relationships have been unsuitable for rare diseases. Methods We applied a topological data analysis (TDA) approach to investigate genotype–phenotype relationships in PCD. Data from separate training and validation cohorts included 396 genetically defined individuals carrying pathogenic variants in PCD genes. To develop the TDA models, 12 clinical and diagnostic variables were included. TDA-driven hypotheses were subsequently tested using traditional statistics. Results Disease severity at diagnosis, measured by forced expiratory volume in 1 s (FEV 1 ) z-score, was significantly worse in individuals with CCDC39 mutations (compared to other gene mutations) and better in those with DNAH11 mutations; the latter also reported less neonatal respiratory distress. Patients without neonatal respiratory distress had better preserved FEV 1 at diagnosis. Individuals with DNAH5 mutations were phenotypically diverse. Cilia ultrastructure and beat pattern defects correlated closely to specific causative gene groups, confirming these tests can be used to support a genetic diagnosis. Conclusions This large scale, multi-national study presents PCD as a syndrome with overlapping symptoms and variations in phenotype according to genotype. TDA modelling confirmed genotype–phenotype relationships reported by smaller studies ( e.g. FEV 1 worse with CCDC39 mutation) and identified new relationships, including FEV 1 preservation with DNAH11 mutations and diversity of severity with DNAH5 mutations.

respiratory system

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Topological data analysis reveals genotype–phenotype relationships in primary ciliary dyskinesia

Understanding primary ciliary dyskinesia

Skewed X-chromosome inactivation drives the proportion of DNAAF6 -defective airway motile cilia and variable expressivity in primary ciliary dyskinesia

Pathogenic variants in CFAP46, CFAP54, CFAP74, and CFAP221 cause Primary Ciliary Dyskinesia with a defective C1d projection of the central apparatus

Chronic airway disease in primary ciliary dyskinesia-spiced with geno-phenotype associations

Ciliopathy Patient Variants Reveal Organelle-Specific Functions for TUBB4B in Axonemal Microtubules

Considerable variability in the clinical and ciliary features of primary ciliary dyskinesia in patients with DNAH5 mutations

Primary Ciliary Dyskinesia: A Clinical Review

The Palestinian primary ciliary dyskinesia population: first results of the diagnostic and genetic spectrum

Transcriptional analysis of primary ciliary dyskinesia airway cells reveals a dedicated cilia glutathione pathway

The genetic framework of primary ciliary dyskinesia assessed by soft computing analysis

Novel Dynein Axonemal Assembly Factor 1 Mutations Identified Using Whole‑exome Sequencing in Patients with Primary Ciliary Dyskinesia

Clinical Manifestations and Genotype of Primary Ciliary Dyskinesia Diagnosed in Korea: Multicenter Study

Associations between respiratory pathogens and lung function in primary ciliary dyskinesia: cross-sectional analysis from the PROVALF-PCD cohort

The prevalence of the defining features of primary ciliary dyskinesia within a cri du chat syndrome cohort

High prevalence of CCDC103 p.His154Pro mutation causing primary ciliary dyskinesia disrupts protein oligomerisation and is associated with normal diagnostic investigations

Analysis of Clinical Characteristics and Gene Variants Associated with Primary Ciliary Dyskinesia

A range of 30%-62% of functioning multiciliated airway cells is sufficient to maintain ciliary airway clearance

Clinical and Genetic Spectrum of Primary Ciliary Dyskinesia in Chinese Patients: a Systematic Review

Ciliary Ultrastructure Assessed by Transmission Electron Microscopy in Adults with Bronchiectasis and Suspected Primary Ciliary Dyskinesia but Inconclusive Genotype

Stepwise genetic approach for the diagnosis of primary ciliary dyskinesia in highly consanguineous populations