No or Low Moderate-to-Vigorous Physical Activity: Focusing on the Least Active as an Additional Approach for Physical Activity Surveillance
Raphael H O Araujo,André O Werneck,R Glenn Weaver,Rafael M Tassitano,Célia S Landman,Gilmar M Jesus,Deborah C Malta,Javier Brazo-Sayavera,Grégore I Mielke,Mark S Tremblay,Danilo R P Silva,Raphael H.O. Araujo,André O. Werneck,R. Glenn Weaver,Rafael M. Tassitano,Célia S. Landman,Gilmar M. Jesus,Deborah C. Malta,Grégore I. Mielke,Mark S. Tremblay,Danilo R.P. Silva
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1123/jpah.2023-0654
2024-03-15
Journal of Physical Activity and Health
Abstract:A cutoff based on no or low MVPA will code people into at least 2 groups, those with no or low MVPA and those with some MVPA. In operational terms, no or low MVPA should be considered as the lowest possible amount of MVPA for an assessment method; therefore, this approach would not need to have a standard way of classification and interpretation. For example, among adults, several studies have used self-reported questionnaires, such as the International Physical Activity Questionnaire (IPAQ) and the Global Physical Activity Questionnaire (GPAQ). 15,16 These questionnaires assess MVPA considering the time spent in each PA domain (ie, work, transport, household, and leisure), where overall MVPA is calculated as the sum of the time spent in each domain assessed. Both GPAQ and IPAQ ask to report activities with at least 10 minutes continuous duration; therefore, in these cases, the no or low MVPA approach might be applied to code those who reported not having performed MVPA as no/low MVPA. Among adolescents, international surveys (eg, GSHS, Health Behaviour in School-aged Children—HBSC) tend to assess the weekly frequency of days with at least 60 minutes of MVPA, with possible answers ranging from 0 to 7 days in the past week. In this case, it is not possible to identify adolescents with 0 minutes of MVPA per week. However, aiming to identify those with no or low MVPA versus some MVPA, the use of a cutoff of less than 1 day per week of 60 minutes per day of MVPA might be considered. The concept of no or low MVPA can also be applied to investigating the PA domains separately, as well as different types of PA. For instance, as both IPAQ and GPAQ use questions that allow an estimate of the time spent in MVPA during leisure time, the approach could be used to determine the prevalence of those with no or low leisure-time PA and help identify specific population groups that should be the target of leisure-related public policies. Furthermore, considering that PA guidelines also recommend specific activities—such as those related to muscle and bone strengthening—investigating these activities from an access/opportunity perspective could identify scenarios concerning subgroups systematically unfavored/disadvantaged (eg, racialized communities and people with lower educational levels). 17 This could result in a call for public policies promoting types of PA that often are related to private structures (eg, gyms). The approach based on no or low MVPA could also indicate that without reducing social inequality, physical inactivity reduction would be more difficult to achieve. Given that many countries assess PA in their national health surveys using methodologies that can be harmonized, the no or low MVPA approach could also be used as an additional approach in global PA surveillance. For instance, for adults, the STEPS (STEPwise approach to noncommunicable diseases risk factor surveillance) uses GPAQ to assess information on PA. Data from STEPS were previously used to estimate the global prevalence of PA and are available from the WHO website by formal request. 18 For adolescents, both GSHS and HBSC (nationally representative school-based health surveys) assess PA among adolescents by the use of a question about the number of days per week with at least 60 minutes per day of MVPA. Similar to STEPS, these data were used for estimating PA among adolescents and data are available on their respective websites. 18,19 Although global PA surveillance has been carried out predominantly by self-report questionnaires, it is important to highlight that the no or low MVPA approach could be also applied with device-based methods, such as accelerometers. However, considering that 0 minutes of MVPA per week would be very rare, specific procedures should be developed to identify thresholds for low MVPA, which could be done, for example, from the distribution of PA in specific populations and through the combination with self-report methods to identify the domains and types of PA.
public, environmental & occupational health