Digital reading: From the reflective self to social machine
Michael Adrian Peters,Petar Jandrić
2016-01-01
Review of Contemporary Philosophy
Abstract:Prologue: The Augustinian Model of ReadingMichael Peters (MP): Chad Wellmon writing for the Hedgehog Review discusses Augustineu0027s faith in the power of reading as a kind of ascent that is transformative. The divine gift of words is the basis of readerly conversion:Augustineu0027s model of reading had a lasting impact in the West. In twelfth-century Paris, Hugh of Saint Victor wrote a manual for students of the Paris cathedral schools on the rules of proper learning. In it, he describes reading as both a technical method governed by rules and a teleological activity aimed at the restoration of the humanu0027s u0027divine likeness.u0027 Practiced properly, he writes, reading u0027takes the soul away from the noise of earthly businessu0027 and offers in this li fe a u0027for etaste of th e sweetn ess of th e et ernal li fe. u0027 Reading exercises the mind and prepares it for meditation, or what Hugh describes as concentrated and sustained thought u0027upon the wonders of God.u0027 (Wellmon, 2015)Reading is divine; writing, by contrast, is dubious given the way that the author cannot control the meanings generated by the text or the way meaning is disseminated. The rise of modern humanism fixed the critical scholarly practices that objectified the text as material objects and offer itself for interpretation outside the sphere of divine intentions.Wittgenstein famously begins the Philosophical Investigations with a quote from Augustineu0027s Confessions: "When grown-ups named some object and at the same time turned towards it, I perceived this, and I grasped that the thing was signified by the sound they uttered, since they meant to point it out." (Augustine, 1.8, in Wittgenstein, 1986: 2) Wittgenstein responds:These words, it seems to me, give us a particular picture of the essence of human language. It is this: the words in language name objects - sentences are combinations of such names. - In this picture of language we find the roots of the following idea: Every word has a meaning. This meaning is correlated with the word. It is the object for which the word stands. (Wittgenstein, 1986: 2)Burnyeat exhibits "the passage Wittgenstein has made famous as the precipitate of some 800 years of Platonist philosophizing" (1987: 3) and corrects the common misunderstanding revealed in the preceding paragraph from the Confessions that Wittgenstein does not quote:Augustine claims that his elders did not teach him to speak. He taught himself. Fewer still, I imagine, will be aware that on this point the adult Augustineu0027s account of his childhood derives from a quite general philosophical thesis to the effect that no man ever does or can teach another anything. (ibid: 1)Of course, learning to speak and learning to read are different but related and overlapping practices of developing understanding as a human being in our increasingly complex form of life. Increasingly, it is clear that we are entering a digital form of life where both reading and writing are transformed, as is speaking."Reading" in "reading lit erature" is no longer and less and less so, an induction or socialization or initiation into a form of life with its own rules and practices. Computational reading, scanning, "distance reading," "texting," "machine reading," "browsing" etc. shed the ritual sacralization and reveal a new instrumental relationship to the text and to the machine. Sven Birkerts writes of "Reading in a Digital Age:"The nature of transition, how change works its way through a system, how people acclimate to the new - all these questions. So much of the change is driven by technologies that are elusive if not altogether invisible in their operation. Signals, data, networks. New habits and reflexes. Watch older people as they try to retool; watch the ease with which kids who have nothing to unlearn go swimming forward. Study their movements, their aptitudes, their weaknesses. I wonder if any population in history has had a bigger gulf between its youngest and oldest members. …