Abstract:Purpose Word‐of‐mouth (WOM) has been found to significantly influence consumers' decision making. Much attention has been paid to the effect of WOM characteristics such as the number of postings, the dispersion of online conversations, the reputation of the reviewers, and the review quality on product sales. Little research, however, has examined the interaction process of online reviews. The purpose of this paper is to investigate the consumers' product attitude formation process in online WOM. Three research questions will be addressed in this paper, i.e. the effect of prior responses on the following repliers' product attitude, the negativity effect and the role of main messages in shaping consumers' product attitude formation process. Design/methodology/approach The product attitude formation process of online WOM is investigated using the data of product reviews (main messages) and their corresponding responses. The paper collected 26 product reviews from various web sites and kept the first 40‐50 responses for each review, which resulted in 26 main messages and 1,173 observations (i.e. responses) in total. A hierarchical Bayesian ordinal choice model is then specified and estimated with the Markov Chain Monte Carlo method to address the research questions and to capture the main message heterogeneity. Findings The paper finds that the impact of prior responses (e.g. the proportion of positive and negative responses) on the product attitudes of the following responses differs significantly across products. This heterogeneity can be well explained by the characteristics of the main messages at the second‐level specification. Thereby, factors that influence consumers' product attitudes in the interaction process of online WOM include prior responses and main message characteristics. Another interesting finding is that positive responses have larger impacts on product attitudes than negative ones. Originality/value This research contributes to both academic research and the firms' online WOM management. Theoretically, this research is the first attempt to examine the formation process of attitudes toward new products in online communications. This research contributes by modeling how the dynamic process of online WOM influences new product attitudes. Furthermore, inconsistent with the “negativity effect” proposed by researchers (e.g. Skowronski and Carlston), the paper finds that positive responses matter more than negative ones in online communications. In addition, the way the paper configures the data for online communications is innovative and provides a perspective to quantitatively model the communication process. Managerially, this research provides implications for firms to intervene in the online communication process and influence consumer attitude of new products.

Do all, or only some personality types engage in spreading negative WOM? An experimental study of negative WOM, big 5 personality traits and brand personality

Prestige and Dominance: How eWOM Differs Between Consumers High in Authentic and Hubristic Pride

Whether and How Prepurchase Word of Mouth Affects Postpurchase Word of Mouth

Beyond Positive and Negative eWOM: The Role of Trust Propensity and Individuation in Shaping Consumers’ Perception of Brand Image

Brand hate, rage, anger & co.: Exploring the relevance and characteristics of negative consumer emotions toward brands

Make a Good Impression: Recommend Different Products for Self-Presentation

The Dark Triad of brand personality: Scale development and validation

More Proximal, More Willing to Purchase: The Mechanism for Variability in Consumers' Purchase Intention Toward Sincere vs. Exciting Brands

Managing Negative Word-of-mouth: the Interplay Between Locus of Causality and Social Presence

Impact of brand anthropomorphism on ethical judgment: the roles of failure type and loneliness

The Role of Personality in COVID-19-Related Perceptions, Evaluations, and Behaviors: Findings Across Five Samples, Nine Traits, and 17 Criteria

The relative impact of employees’ discrete emotions on employees’ negative word-of-mouth (NWOM) and counterproductive workplace behavior (CWB)

Hubristic pride & prejudice: The effects of hubristic pride on negative word-of-mouth

The Effects of Brand Crisis on Consumer Negative Emotions: Focused on Crisis Causes and Brand Personality

Modeling product attitude formation process in online word‐of‐mouth

The Big Five Personality Traits as Predictors of Negative Emotional States in University Students in Taiwan

Will Great Power Come with Great Responsibility Only? A Dual Model of Consumer Power and Negative WOM on Social Media Review Platforms

The Effect of Customer Satisfaction on Word-of-Mouth Communication: The Mediating Role of Face Perception

The impact of interpersonal traits (extraversion and agreeableness) on consumers’ self-brand connection and communal-brand connection with anthropomorphized brands

Influences of Emotion and Negative Online Word-Of-Mouth (WoM) on Nissan Motor Co., Ltd.

Toward Understanding Consumer Processing of Negative Online Word-of-Mouth Communication