Abstract:ABSTRACT Heteroresistance refers to phenotypic heterogeneity of microbial clonal populations under antibiotic stress, and it has been thought to be an allocation of a subset of “resistant” cells for surviving in higher concentrations of antibiotic. The assumption fits the so-called bet-hedging strategy, where a bacterial population “hedges” its “bet” on different phenotypes to be selected by unpredicted environment stresses. To test this hypothesis, we constructed a heteroresistance model by introducing a blaCTX-M-14 gene (coding for a cephalosporin hydrolase) into a sensitive Escherichia coli strain. We confirmed heteroresistance in this clone and that a subset of the cells expressed more hydrolase and formed more colonies in the presence of ceftriaxone (exhibited stronger “resistance”). However, subsequent single-cell-level investigation by using a microfluidic device showed that a subset of cells with a distinguishable phenotype of slowed growth and intensified hydrolase expression emerged, and they were not positively selected but increased their proportion in the population with ascending antibiotic concentrations. Therefore, heteroresistance—the gradually decreased colony-forming capability in the presence of antibiotic—was a result of a decreased growth rate rather than of selection for resistant cells. Using a mock strain without the resistance gene, we further demonstrated the existence of two nested growth-centric feedback loops that control the expression of the hydrolase and maximize population growth in various antibiotic concentrations. In conclusion, phenotypic heterogeneity is a population-based strategy beneficial for bacterial survival and propagation through task allocation and interphenotypic collaboration, and the growth rate provides a critical control for the expression of stress-related genes and an essential mechanism in responding to environmental stresses. IMPORTANCE Heteroresistance is essentially phenotypic heterogeneity, where a population-based strategy is thought to be at work, being assumed to be variable cell-to-cell resistance to be selected under antibiotic stress. Exact mechanisms of heteroresistance and its roles in adaptation to antibiotic stress have yet to be fully understood at the molecular and single-cell levels. In our study, we have not been able to detect any apparent subset of “resistant” cells selected by antibiotics; on the contrary, cell populations differentiate into phenotypic subsets with variable growth statuses and hydrolase expression. The growth rate appears to be sensitive to stress intensity and plays a key role in controlling hydrolase expression at both the bulk population and single-cell levels. We have shown here, for the first time, that phenotypic heterogeneity can be beneficial to a growing bacterial population through task allocation and interphenotypic collaboration other than partitioning cells into different categories of selective advantage.

Dynamic gene expression and growth underlie cell-to-cell heterogeneity in Escherichia coli stress response

Dynamic heterogeneity in an E. coli stress response regulon mediates gene activation and antimicrobial peptide tolerance

Pre-Disposition and Epigenetics Govern Variation in Bacterial Survival upon Stress

Control of nongenetic heterogeneity in growth rate and stress tolerance of Saccharomyces cerevisiae by cyclic AMP-regulated transcription factors

Heterogeneity of stress gene expression and stress resistance among individual cells of Saccharomyces cerevisiae

Bacteria differently regulate mRNA abundance to specifically respond to various stresses.

Evaluating the predictive power of combined gene expression dynamics from single cells on antibiotic survival

Phenotypic Heterogeneity in Mycobacterial Stringent Response

A simple regulatory network coordinates a bacterial stress response in space and time

Forecasting cell fate during antibiotic exposure using stochastic gene expression

Single-cell data reveal heterogeneity of resource allocation across a bacterial population

Gene expression tradeoffs determine bacterial survival and adaptation to antibiotic stress

Links between Transcription, Environmental Adaptation and Gene Variability in Escherichia coli: Correlations between Gene Expression and Gene Variability Reflect Growth Efficiencies.

Forecasting when cells die during antibiotic exposure using stochastic gene expression

Single-cell Growth Rate Variability in Balanced Exponential Growth

Heteroresistance at the Single-Cell Level: Adapting to Antibiotic Stress Through a Population-Based Strategy and Growth-Controlled Interphenotypic Coordination

Growth suppression by altered (p)ppGpp levels results from non-optimal resource allocation in Escherichia coli

Stochasticity of metabolism and growth at the single-cell level

Gene expression profiling of Escherichia coli growth transitions: an expanded stringent response model

Dose dependent gene expression is dynamically modulated by the history, physiology and age of yeast cells

Single-strain mobilome sequencing quantifies bacterial genetic response to stress, including activity of IS elements, prophages, RNAs, and REPINs.