A Series of Pure Ankle Dislocations without Associated Fracture: Our Clinical Experience

Tingjiang Gan,Yaxing Li,Wei Deng,Boquan Qin,Xi Liu,Hui Zhang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-251242/v1

2021-02-23

Abstract:Abstract Background: Pure ankle dislocation without associated fracture is extremely rare, thus the literature almost limited to case reports and small case series. The standardized treatment protocol is in controversy and the studies of mechanism and outcome of the injury are still deficient. We report a series of eight cases of pure tibiotalar dislocations managed with emergency reduction and other heterogenic procedures, hoping to add some material to the published data on this topic and present our clinical experience.Methods: We retrospectively reviewed the eight cases of isolated ankle dislocations without associated fracture that were treated in our department from 2015 to 2019. Results: The eight cases were all posteromedial dislocations with six open and two closed. Emergency reduction was performed for all patients followed by average 6 weeks’ immobilization with external fixators in five and short leg cast in three. The mean follow-up period was 33 (range, 12 to 61) months. None of the eight patients showed obvious instability though only one patient underwent ligaments repair. The average range of motion (ROM) loss of the ankles was 10 degrees for plantarflexion and 3 degrees for dorsiflexion. Two patients complained of moderate stiffness and three complained of persistent mild pain in whom degenerative change was found. Neurovascular sequela was presented in one patient with numbness. Only one patient developed superficial infection. The average AOFAS score was 90 (range, 78 to 100) points at the final follow-up with five ankles rated as excellent and three rated as good. All of the eight patients returned to their prior daily life and the two closed patients with sports injuries resumed sports activity.Conclusion: Pure ankle dislocation is a rare ligamentous ankle injury with complicated mechanism. Most of the injuries treated with emergency reduction and thorough debridement followed by a short period of immobilization and functional rehabilitation have good clinical outcomes. Ligaments repair should only be considered in cases of chronic ankle instability after failed conservative treatment.