Abstract:BackgroundMany factors can affect a surgeon’s performance in the operating room; these may include surgeon comfort, ergonomics of tool handle design, and fatigue. A laparoscopic tool handle designed with ergonomic considerations (pistol grip) was tested against a current market tool with a traditional pinch grip handle. The goal of this study is to quantify the impact ergonomic design considerations which have on surgeon performance. We hypothesized that there will be measurable differences between the efficiency while performing FLS surgical trainer tasks when using both tool handle designs in three categories: time to completion, technical skill, and subjective user ratings.MethodsThe pistol grip incorporates an ergonomic interface intended to reduce contact stress points on the hand and fingers, promote a more neutral operating wrist posture, and reduce hand tremor and fatigue. The traditional pinch grip is a laparoscopic tool developed by Stryker Inc. widely used during minimal invasive surgery. Twenty-three (13 M, 10 F) participants with no existing upper extremity musculoskeletal disorders or experience performing laparoscopic procedures were selected to perform in this study. During a training session prior to testing, participants performed practice trials in a SAGES FLS trainer with both tools. During data collection, participants performed three evaluation tasks using both handle designs (order was randomized, and each trial completed three times). The tasks consisted of FLS peg transfer, cutting, and suturing tasks.ResultsFeedback from test participants indicated that they significantly preferred the ergonomic pistol grip in every category (p < 0.05); most notably, participants experienced greater degrees of discomfort in their hands after using the pinch grip tool. Furthermore, participants completed cutting and peg transfer tasks in a shorter time duration (p < 0.05) with the pistol grip than with the pinch grip design; there was no significant difference between completion times for the suturing task. Finally, there was no significant interaction between tool type and errors made during trials.ConclusionsThere was a significant preference for as well as lower pain experienced during use of the pistol grip tool as seen from the survey feedback. Both evaluation tasks (cutting and peg transfer) were also completed significantly faster with the pistol grip tool. Finally, due to the high degree of variability in the error data, it was not possible to draw any meaningful conclusions about the effect of tool design on the number or degree of errors made.

Effects of handle characteristics of manual hand tools on maximal torque exertions: a literature review

Evaluation of handle design characteristics in a maximum screwdriving torque task

Analysis of the Handle Cross-section Design of Cordless Drill Screwdriver

Assessment of ergonomically designed handle shapes for low-frequency vibration responses

The effect of handle friction and inward or outward torque on maximum axial push force

The relationship between hand anthropometrics, total grip strength and individual finger force for various handle shapes

Effect of Handle Design and Target Location on Wrist Posture during Aiming with a Laparoscopic Tool

Comparative Study of the Use of Different Sizes of an Ergonomic Instrument Handle for Laparoscopic Surgery

A Review on Grip and Pinch Strength Tests

Ergonomic hand tool design.

Study of the effect of hand-arm vibration on hand grip strength

Ergonomics investigation for orientation of the handles of wood routers

The effect of handle design on upper extremity posture and muscle activity during a pouring task

Ergonomic Design and Assessment of an Improved Handle for a Laparoscopic Dissector Based on 3D Anthropometry

The effect of ergonomic laparoscopic tool handle design on performance and efficiency

Objective and subjective evaluation of various aspects of hand performance considering protective glove’s constructional parameters

Individual customization strategy accomplished by developing prototype of a laparoscopic forceps handle using additive manufacturing

Survey on Surgical Instrument Handle Design

Impact of novel shift handle laparoscopic tool on wrist ergonomics and task performance

Recommendations for tool-handle material choice based on finite element analysis

Hand Tool Intervention for Rubber Tappers Using Modified Michie Golledge Knife