Abstract:When making decisions in everyday life, we often rely on an internally generated sense of confidence to help us revise and direct future behaviours. For instance, confidence directly informs whether further information should be sought prior to commitment to a final decision. Many studies have shown that aging and both clinical and sub-clinical symptoms of psychopathology are associated with systematic alterations in confidence. However, it remains unknown whether these confidence distortions influence information-seeking behaviour. We investigated this question in a large general population sample (N = 908). Participants completed a battery of psychiatric symptom questionnaires and performed a perceptual decision-making task with confidence ratings in which they were offered the option to seek helpful information (at a cost) before committing to a final decision. Replicating previous findings, an 'anxious-depression' (AD) symptom dimension was associated with systematically low confidence, despite no detriment in objective task accuracy. Conversely, a 'compulsive behaviour and intrusive thoughts' (CIT) dimension was associated with impaired task accuracy but paradoxical over-confidence. However, neither symptom dimension was significantly associated with an increased or decreased tendency to seek information. Hence, participants scoring highly for AD or CIT did not use the option to information seek any more than average to either increase their confidence (AD) or improve the accuracy of their decisions (CIT). In contrast, older age was associated with impaired accuracy and decreased confidence initially, but increased information seeking behaviour mediated increases in both accuracy and confidence for final decisions. Hence, older adults used the information seeking option to overcome initial deficits in objective performance and to increase their confidence accordingly. The results show an appropriate use of information seeking to overcome perceptual deficits and low confidence in healthy aging which was not present in transdiagnostic psychopathology.

Metacognitive Computations for Information Search: Confidence in Control

Metacognitive Information Theory

Metacognition and Confidence: A Review and Synthesis.

Individual Inferences in Web-Based Information Environments: How Cognitive Processing Fluency, Information Access, Active Search Behaviors, and Task Competency Affect Metacognitive and Task Judgments

Assumptions and confidence of others: the impact of socio-cognitive information on metacognitive self-regulation

Optimal metacognitive control of memory recall.

Metacognitive experiences as information: Processing fluency in consumer judgment and decision making

The online metacognitive control of decisions

Information search under uncertainty across transdiagnostic psychopathology and healthy ageing

Wanting information: Uncertainty and its reduction through search engagement

Research on Metacognitive Regulation of Learning-oriented Search Behavior Process

Toward 'Computational-Rationality' Approaches to Arbitrating Models of Cognition: A Case Study Using Perceptual Metacognition

A confidence framing effect: Flexible use of evidence in metacognitive monitoring

Metacognition of curiosity: People underestimate the seductive lure of non-instrumental information

Search Fluency Mistaken for Understanding: Ease of Information Retrieval from the Internet Inflates Internal Knowledge Confidence

Action information contributes to metacognitive decision-making

On the assumptions behind metacognitive measurements: Implications for theory and practice

Metacognitive monitoring and control in distributed cognition

A decision-congruent heuristic gives superior metacognitive sensitivity under realistic variance assumptions.

Metacognitive phenomena during human–Internet interactions

Metacognition & conceptual drifting in interactive information retrieval: An exploratory field study