Abstract:It is important that climate models can accurately simulate the terrestrial carbon cycle in the Arctic due to the large and potentially labile carbon stocks found in permafrost-affected environments, which can lead to a positive climate feedback, along with the possibility of future carbon sinks from northward expansion of vegetation under climate warming. Here we evaluate the simulation of tundra carbon stocks and fluxes in three land surface schemes that each form part of major Earth system models (JSBACH, Germany; JULES, UK; ORCHIDEE, France). We use a site-level approach in which comprehensive, high-frequency datasets allow us to disentangle the importance of different processes. The models have improved physical permafrost processes and there is a reasonable correspondence between the simulated and measured physical variables, including soil temperature, soil moisture and snow. We show that if the models simulate the correct leaf area index (LAI), the standard C3 photosynthesis schemes produce the correct order of magnitude of carbon fluxes. Therefore, simulating the correct LAI is one of the first priorities. LAI depends quite strongly on climatic variables alone, as we see by the fact that the dynamic vegetation model can simulate most of the differences in LAI between sites, based almost entirely on climate inputs. However, we also identify an influence from nutrient limitation as the LAI becomes too large at some of the more nutrient-limited sites. We conclude that including moss as well as vascular plants is of primary importance to the carbon budget, as moss contributes a large fraction to the seasonal CO2 flux in nutrient-limited conditions. Moss photosynthetic activity can be strongly influenced by the moisture content of moss, and the carbon uptake can be significantly different from vascular plants with a similar LAI. The soil carbon stocks depend strongly on the rate of input of carbon from the vegetation to the soil, and our analysis suggests that an improved simulation of photosynthesis would also lead to an improved simulation of soil carbon stocks. However, the stocks are also influenced by soil carbon burial (e.g. through cryoturbation) and the rate of heterotrophic respiration, which depends on the soil physical state. More detailed below-ground measurements are needed to fully evaluate biological and physical soil processes. Furthermore, even if these processes are well modelled, the soil carbon profiles cannot resemble peat layers as peat accumulation processes are not represented in the models. Thus, we identify three priority areas for model development: (1) dynamic vegetation including (a) climate and (b) nutrient limitation effects; (2) adding moss as a plant functional type; and an (3) improved vertical profile of soil carbon including peat processes.

Grassland dynamics of soil moisture and temperature

Sensitivity of montane grassland water fluxes to warming and elevated CO 2 from local to catchment scale: A case study from the Austrian Alps

Atmospheric water vapor and soil moisture jointly determine the spatiotemporal variations of CO2 fluxes and evapotranspiration across the Qinghai-Tibetan Plateau grasslands

Drivers of carbon fluxes in Alpine tundra: a comparison of three empirical model approaches

Numerical Simulation Research of Land Surface Process in the Region Between Cropland and Pasture

Spatiotemporal variability of evapotranspiration in Alpine grasslands and its biotic and abiotic drivers

Carbon dioxide exchanges in an alpine tundra ecosystem (Gran Paradiso National Park, Italy): A comparison of results from different measurement and modelling approaches

Characterization of Soil Organic Matter along an elevation gradient at Stelvio Pass (Italian Alps).

Carbon and water fluxes and their coupling in an alpine meadow ecosystem on the northeastern Tibetan Plateau

Soil water balance and ecosystem response to climate change

Variations in Bedrock and Vegetation Cover Modulate Subsurface Water Flow Dynamics of a Mountainous Hillslope

Challenges and opportunities of quantifying local CO2 advection at a mountain forest in the Alps

Spatial and temporal variability of carbon dioxide fluxes in the Alpine Critical Zone: The case of the Nivolet Plain, Gran Paradiso National Park, Italy

Root‐zone soil moisture variability across African savannas: From pulsed rainfall to land‐cover switches

Representing the effects of alpine grassland vegetation cover on the simulation of soil thermal dynamics by ecosystem models applied to the Qinghai-Tibetan Plateau

Atmosphere-surface fluxes modeling for the high Andes: The case of páramo catchments of Ecuador

Carbon Stocks and Fluxes in the High Latitudes: Using Site-Level Data to Evaluate Earth System Models

Soil properties across a hydrological gradient in saladas from northeast Spain: what are the implications for soil carbon stocks, CO2 efflux and microbial communities in a warming world?

Site-Level Model Intercomparison of High Latitude and High Altitude Soil Thermal Dynamics in Tundra and Barren Landscapes

Observational and Modelling Investigations of Land-Precipitation Coupling

Evaluating the Interplay Between Biophysical Processes and Leaf Area Changes in Land Surface Models