The misogyny of iron deficiency

C. Dugan,B. MacLean,K. Cabolis,S. Abeysiri,A. Khong,M. Sajic,T. Richards,the Women's Health research Collaborative,

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/anae.15432

IF: 12.893

2021-03-07

Anaesthesia

Abstract:<p>Anaemia is common, particularly in women and the commonest underlying cause, iron deficiency, is often overlooked. Anaemia is associated with increased morbidity and mortality in patients undergoing anaesthesia; however, women are defined as being anaemic at a lower haemoglobin level than men. In this narrative review, we present the history of iron deficiency anaemia and how women's health has often been overlooked. Iron deficiency was first described as 'chlorosis' and a cause of 'hysteria' in women and initial treatment was by iron filings in cold wine. We present data of population screening demonstrating how common iron deficiency is, affecting 12–18% of apparently 'fit and healthy' women, with the most common cause being heavy menstrual bleeding; both conditions being often unrecognised. We describe a range of symptoms reported by women, that vary from fatigue to brain fog, hair loss and eating ice. We also describe experiments exploring the physical impact of iron deficiency, showing that reduced exercise performance is related to iron deficiency independent of haemoglobin concentration, as well as the impact of iron supplementation in women improving oxygen consumption and fitness. Overall, we demonstrate the need to single out women and investigate iron deficiency rather than accept the dogma of normality and differential treatment; this is to say, the need to change the current standard of care for women undergoing anaesthesia.</p>

anesthesiology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the under - diagnosis and under - treatment of iron deficiency in women. Specifically, the paper focuses on the following aspects:

1. **History and gender bias of iron deficiency**: The paper reviews the history of iron deficiency, especially its relationship with women's health, and points out that historically, iron deficiency was once misidentified as the "hysterical" symptom unique to women, and early treatment methods also had gender bias.

2. **Prevalence of iron deficiency**: The paper shows the prevalence of iron deficiency in women through multiple research data, especially in seemingly healthy populations. Studies indicate that approximately 12% to 18% of healthy women suffer from anemia, and the proportion of iron deficiency is even higher, which may affect one - third of women.

3. **Symptoms of iron deficiency**: The paper describes in detail the symptoms of iron deficiency, which include not only fatigue, dizziness and dyspnea, but also cognitive decline (such as "brain fog"), muscle weakness, hair loss and pica (such as eating ice). These symptoms often appear in the early stage of iron deficiency, even when the hemoglobin level has not dropped significantly.

4. **Impact of iron deficiency on physical performance**: Through animal experiments and human studies, the paper explores the impact of iron deficiency on cardiovascular and muscle functions. The study finds that iron deficiency can lead to a decline in exercise capacity, even when the hemoglobin level is normal. Iron supplementation can significantly improve these symptoms and enhance exercise performance.

5. **Screening and diagnosis of iron deficiency**: The paper emphasizes the importance of screening for iron deficiency in women and recommends adding the detection of hemoglobin and ferritin in routine medical examinations to identify and treat iron deficiency earlier.

Overall, the paper aims to raise awareness of iron deficiency in women, change the current diagnostic criteria and treatment strategies, so as to improve women's health status and quality of life.