Climate is changing, are European bats too? A multispecies analysis of trends in body size
Danilo Russo,Gareth Jones,Adriano Martinoli,Damiano G. Preatoni,Martina Spada,Andrea Pereswiet‐Soltan,Luca Cistrone
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/ece3.10872
IF: 3.167
2024-02-08
Ecology and Evolution
Abstract:This study spanning over 20 years and involving 15 bat species in Italy challenges the expectation of a widespread increase in body size in response to climate change. Contrary to predictions, only three out of the 15 species exhibited a noticeable size increase, prompting a revaluation of bats as reliable indicators of climate change based on body size alterations. We identify temperature‐related variables, sexual dimorphism, latitude, and altitude as crucial factors influencing bat body size dynamics, revealing a nuanced interplay that adds complexity to our understanding of how bats respond to environmental changes over time and space. Animal size, a trait sensitive to spatial and temporal variables, is a key element in ecological and evolutionary dynamics. In the context of climate change, there is evidence that some bat species are increasing their body size via phenotypic responses to higher temperatures at maternity roosts. To test the generality of this response, we conducted a >20‐year study examining body size changes in 15 bat species in Italy, analysing data from 4393 individual bats captured since 1995. In addition to examining the temporal effect, we considered the potential influence of sexual dimorphism and, where relevant, included latitude and altitude as potential drivers of body size change. Contrary to initial predictions of a widespread increase in size, our findings challenge this assumption, revealing a nuanced interplay of factors contributing to the complexity of bat body size dynamics. Specifically, only three species (Myotis daubentonii, Nyctalus leisleri, and Pipistrellus pygmaeus) out of the 15 exhibited a discernible increase in body size over the studied period, prompting a reassessment of bats as reliable indicators of climate change based on alterations in body size. Our investigation into influencing factors highlighted the significance of temperature‐related variables, with latitude and altitude emerging as crucial drivers. In some cases, this mirrored patterns consistent with Bergmann's rule, revealing larger bats recorded at progressively higher latitudes (Plecotus auritus, Myotis mystacinus, and Miniopterus schreibersii) or altitudes (Pipistrellus kuhlii). We also observed a clear sexual dimorphism effect in most species, with females consistently larger than males. The observed increase in size over time in three species suggests the occurrence of phenotypic plasticity, raising questions about potential long‐term selective pressures on larger individuals. The unresolved question of whether temperature‐related changes in body size reflect microevolutionary processes or phenotypic plastic responses adds further complexity to our understanding of body size patterns in bats over time and space.
ecology,evolutionary biology