Abstract:Multivoxel pattern analysis (MVPA) examines the differences in fMRI activation patterns associated with different cognitive conditions and provides information not possible with the conventional univariate analysis. Support vector machines (SVMs) are the predominant machine learning method in MVPA. SVMs are intuitive and easy to apply. The limitation is that it is a linear method and mainly suitable for analyzing data that are linearly separable. Convolutional neural networks (CNNs), a class of AI models originally developed for object recognition, are known to have the ability to approximate nonlinear relationships. CNNs are rapidly becoming an alternative to SVMs. The purpose of this study is to compare the two methods when they are applied to the same datasets. Two datasets were considered: (1) fMRI data collected from participants during a cued visual spatial attention task (the attention dataset) and (2) fMRI data collected from participants viewing natural images containing varying degrees of affective content (the emotion dataset). We found that (1) both SVM and CNN are able to achieve above chance level decoding accuracies for attention control and emotion processing in both the primary visual cortex and the whole brain with, (2) the CNN decoding accuracies are consistently higher than that of the SVM, (3) the SVM and CNN decoding accuracies are generally not correlated with each other, and (4) the heatmaps derived from SVM and CNN are not significantly overlapping. These results suggest that (1) there are both linearly separable features and nonlinearly separable features in fMRI data that distinguish cognitive conditions and (2) applying both SVM and CNN to the same data may yield a more comprehensive understanding of neuroimaging data. Key points: We compared the performance and characteristics of SVM and CNN, two major methods in MVPA analysis of neuroimaging data, by applying them to the same two fMRI datasets.Both SVM and CNN achieved decoding accuracies above chance level for both datasets in the chosen ROIs and the CNN decoding accuracies were consistently higher than those of SVM.The heatmaps derived from SVM and CNN, which assess the contribution of voxels or brain regions to MVPA decoding performance, showed no significant overlap, providing evidence that the two methods depend on distinct brain activity patterns for decoding cognitive conditions.

Decoding Categories from Human Brain Activity in the Human Visual Cortex Using the Triplet Network

Category Decoding of Visual Stimuli From Human Brain Activity Using a Bidirectional Recurrent Neural Network to Simulate Bidirectional Information Flows in Human Visual Cortices

Decoding Visual fMRI Stimuli from Human Brain Based on Graph Convolutional Neural Network

Long short‐term memory‐based neural decoding of object categories evoked by natural images

Multimodal deep neural decoding reveals highly resolved spatiotemporal profile of visual object representation in humans

Decoding fMRI data with support vector machines and deep neural networks

STN: a new tensor network method to identify stimulus category from brain activity pattern

Decoding fMRI Data: A Comparison Between Support Vector Machines and Deep Neural Networks

‘When’ and ‘what’ did you see? A novel fMRI-based visual decoding framework

Decoding visual stimuli in human brain by using Anatomical Pattern Analysis on fMRI images

Decoding Visual Neural Representations by Multimodal Learning of Brain-Visual-Linguistic Features

Multi-pooling 3D Convolutional Neural Network for fMRI Classification of Visual Brain States

Decoding human brain activity with deep learning

Exploring Brain Effective Connectivity in Visual Perception Using a Hierarchical Correlation Network.

Learning to Decode Cognitive States from Brain Images

A Hybrid Spatio-Temporal Deep Belief Network and Sparse Representation-Based Framework Reveals Multi-Level Core Functional Components in Decoding Multi-Task fMRI Signals

Decoding Visual Feature Versus Visual Spatial Attention Control with Deep Neural Networks

Decoding and mapping task states of the human brain via deep learning

Reconstruction of Natural Images from Human fMRI Using a Three-Stage Multi-Level Deep Fusion Model

Unidirectional brain-computer interface: Artificial neural network encoding natural images to fMRI response in the visual cortex

Explainable MST-ECoGNet Decode Visual Information from ECoG Signal