Abstract:Purpose The purpose of this paper is to investigate the role of preferences when small and medium enterprises (SMEs) are confronted with the practical problems associated with implementing frequent and large-scale changes to their working policies and practices. This paper aims to alleviate some of the concerns as claimed in positioning and change agency theory by introducing “preferential role positioning” to organizational change. Design/methodology/approach This study uses a qualitative case study approach and change agency and positioning theories to find out the extent to which staff and management experienced the practical difficulties and challenges and what resolution actions they took. Eighty-five semi-structured interviews were conducted in 2004/2005 and 2011 with the staff and management of four SMEs in the UK. An interpretative analysis was conducted on the case data in the tradition of Husserl and Schutz. In the first set, participants were asked to elucidate the difficulties faced in their roles and how these were experienced whilst the second focused on impacts and strategies. Three independent researchers reviewed and interpreted the qualitative data and helped with the coding and thematization. Findings This paper's main results are based on the data's three stages showing how SME members chose to deal with the practical difficulties namely “new structures and procedures” (stage 1); “new ways of communicating” (stage 2) and “new collaborations” (stage 3). The combination of the stages' aspects led to the emergence of “preferential role positioning” as the study's theoretical contribution to the gap on preferences in organizational change research. Research limitations/implications The eighty-five interviews from UK-based SMEs constrained the sample size thereby limiting the number of questionnaire categories asked. The findings and their analysis cannot be generalized to non-SMEs that seek to address similar difficulties. Practical implications Managers need to be aware of the adverse impacts of using draconian, top-down disciplinary and punishment measures/structures as a way to implement change. Other practical lessons include the fact that managers should contextualize people's anxieties, dissatisfaction, resistance and disengagement as a platform from which social knowledge can be generated with all change agents in order to resolve implementation challenges in the longer term. Staff developed the ability to deal with some practical issues such as navigating through the new departmental structures, new working procedures and new ways of talking with management and with each other to implement change more successfully. Social implications The social value of the findings demonstrates that preferences can be imported from other social science disciplines into Organizational Studies to show the value of what people can contribute and how they choose to do so (i.e. via what discourse, using what types of interactions and capabilities to do so). In addition, the results show that management need to consider employees in their plans as they try to implement change firstly to facilitate greater interaction and success, secondly to minimize implementation difficulties and thirdly as a recognition that there are multiple change agents and multiple role-enacting positions in developing sociological knowledge that can be of value. Originality/value This study's three-stage approach has shown that a successful implementation and management of change in SMEs should also include a bottom-up recognition of the difficulties, adversities, conflicts and tensions and a resolution to deal with the structural and communicative constraints via dialogue and “preferential role positioning”.

‘Beyond the clash?’: Union–management partnership through social dialogue on sustainable HRM. Lessons from Belgium

Revitalizing social dialogue in the workplace: the impact of a cooperative industrial relations climate and sustainable HR practices on reducing employee harm

Managing Human Resources Across Cultures: a Comparative Analysis of Practices in Industrial Enterprises in China and the Netherlands

Staff preferences in four SMEs experiencing organizational change

Have Labour-Management Partnership Agreements Been Successful?

Dialogues in Sustainable HRM: Examining and Positioning Intended and Continuous Dialogue in Sustainable HRM Using a Complexity Thinking Approach

Sustainable Human Resources Management and Psychological Contracts: Exploring Theoretical Anchors to Solve Relational Tensions in Employment Relationships

Sustainable HRM: Bridging theory and practice through the ‘Respect Openness Continuity (ROC)’-model

How Do Industrial Relations Climate and Union Instrumentality Enhance Employee Performance? the Mediating Effects of Perceived Job Security and Trust in Management

Greening labour? The role of the SDGs in fostering sustainability integration within trade unions

Addressing social-business tensions in hybridized nonprofit organizations: The contribution of strategic human resource management

Towards Common Ground and Trading Zones in Management Research and Practice

Organizational career management practices

Leading hybrid organisations: the contribution of "leadership beacons", emotional transcendence, and transitional space to cross organisational collaboration

Managing Workplace Job Attitudes and Performance in Organizations with Labor Unions

Translating European Labor Relations Practices to the United States Through Global Framework Agreements? German and Swedish Multinationals Compared

Sustainable strategies, employee competencies and social outcomes: are they aligned?

Opening the black box of works council–management team interaction: Germany and the Netherlands compared

Class politics, collective labor rights, and worker-management conflict in comparative perspective

Managing Inter-University Digital Collaboration from a Bottom-Up Approach: Lessons from Organizational, Pedagogical, and Technological Dimensions

Partnership Practices, Labor Relations Climate, and Employee Attitudes: Evidence from China