Abstract:Background: This research delves into the critical aspects of identity management, access control, and authorization practices within the domains of public and private universities. Identity management involves the meticulous management and control of user identities, encompassing the establishment and maintenance of user profiles, role assignments, and access privileges. Access control is the practice of defining and enforcing policies that govern who can access an IT system or application and which resources they can interact with. Authorization, meanwhile, determines the specific actions and privileges granted to users based on their roles and permissions. Methods: To understand the variances in identity management and access control approaches, we conducted a comparative analysis between public and private universities. Our investigation scrutinized the user populations with access to university systems, the enforcement of access limitations, authentication methods, and password policies. Additionally, we examined the nuances of authorization processes, levels of authorization, access approval authorities, user status and role changes, unique user account management, account deletion procedures, user authentication methods, password complexity and expiration policies, password storage methods, and session termination policies. Results: This study revealed that both public and private universities prioritize these security measures, with a common categorization of these processes. Nevertheless, there exist disparities, such as the inclusion of contractors and vendors in the user population at private universities, the manual deletion of user accounts in private institutions, and variations in password policies and storage methods. Private universities tend to enforce stricter password policies, employ more secure password storage methods, and implement automatic session termination features. Conclusions: This research provides valuable insights into the practices and approaches adopted by public and private universities to safeguard their digital environments. The findings serve as a valuable resource for enhancing identity management, access control, and authorization protocols, enabling institutions to fortify their cybersecurity defenses in an ever-evolving threat landscape.

Safety in numbers: security on campus and the importance of the corporatization of universities

The co-production of campus safety and security: a case study at the University of Georgia

College Student Perceptions of Campus Safety Initiatives

Perceptions of Campus Safety Policies: Contrasting the Views of Students with Faculty and Staff

Assessing the influence of technological innovations and community-based facilities management on the safety and security of universities. A case study of an open campus

A Geospatial Mixed Methods Approach to Assessing Campus Safety

Student perceptions of campus safety: testing the vulnerability and disorder models

Are Institutions of Higher Learning Safe? A Descriptive Study of Campus Safety Issues and Self‐Reported Campus Victimization among Male and Female College Students

On-campus student accommodation safety measures: provision versus risk analysis

Reputational Risk as a Logic of Organizing in Late Modernity

Relationship between Natural Surveillance and Fear of Crime among Students: The Case of a Kenyan University

Should we wear a velvet glove to enforce Information security policies in higher education?

Physical security culture: The neglected foundation for effective security

Information security policies’ compliance: a perspective for higher education institutions

"What Keeps People Secure is That They Met The Security Team": Deconstructing Drivers And Goals of Organizational Security Awareness

Fear of Crime at School

Are students aware of, knowledgeable about, and willing to use campus safety services?

Is Campus a Place of (In)Security and Crime? Perceptions and Predictors among Higher Education Students

Comparative analysis of identity management, access control, and authorization practices in public and private universities

Effects of Students' Perceived Safety of Public Outdoor Environment on Academic Achievement at University Campus