Abstract:Artificial neural networks (ANNs), a popular path towards artificial intelligence, have experienced remarkable success via mature models, various benchmarks, open-source datasets, and powerful computing platforms. Spiking neural networks (SNNs), a category of promising models to mimic the neuronal dynamics of the brain, have gained much attention for brain inspired computing and been widely deployed on neuromorphic devices. However, for a long time, there are ongoing debates and skepticisms about the value of SNNs in practical applications. Except for the low power attribute benefit from the spike-driven processing, SNNs usually perform worse than ANNs especially in terms of the application accuracy. Recently, researchers attempt to address this issue by borrowing learning methodologies from ANNs, such as backpropagation, to train high-accuracy SNN models. The rapid progress in this domain continuously produces amazing results with ever-increasing network size, whose growing path seems similar to the development of deep learning. Although these ways endow SNNs the capability to approach the accuracy of ANNs, the natural superiorities of SNNs and the way to outperform ANNs are potentially lost due to the use of ANN-oriented workloads and simplistic evaluation metrics. In this paper, we take the visual recognition task as a case study to answer the questions of "what workloads are ideal for SNNs and how to evaluate SNNs makes sense". We design a series of contrast tests using different types of datasets (ANN-oriented and SNN-oriented), diverse processing models, signal conversion methods, and learning algorithms. We propose comprehensive metrics on the application accuracy and the cost of memory & compute to evaluate these models, and conduct extensive experiments. We evidence the fact that on ANN-oriented workloads, SNNs fail to beat their ANN counterparts; while on SNN-oriented workloads, SNNs can fully perform better. We further demonstrate that in SNNs there exists a trade-off between the application accuracy and the execution cost, which will be affected by the simulation time window and firing threshold. Based on these abundant analyses, we recommend the most suitable model for each scenario. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first work using systematical comparisons to explicitly reveal that the straightforward workload porting from ANNs to SNNs is unwise although many works are doing so and a comprehensive evaluation indeed matters. Finally, we highlight the urgent need to build a benchmarking framework for SNNs with broader tasks, datasets, and metrics.

Comparison of Artificial and Spiking Neural Networks on Digital Hardware

BitSNNs: Revisiting Energy-efficient Spiking Neural Networks

Advancing Neural Networks: Innovations and Impacts on Energy Consumption

Are SNNs Really More Energy-Efficient Than ANNs? an In-Depth Hardware-Aware Study

Computing with hardware neurons: spiking or classical? Perspectives of applied Spiking Neural Networks from the hardware side

You Only Spike Once: Improving Energy-Efficient Neuromorphic Inference to ANN-Level Accuracy

To Spike or Not To Spike: A Digital Hardware Perspective on Deep Learning Acceleration

Synaptic Activity and Hardware Footprint of Spiking Neural Networks in Digital Neuromorphic Systems

A Review of Artificial Spiking Neuron Devices for Neural Processing and Sensing

Reconsidering the energy efficiency of spiking neural networks

Benchmarking Artificial Neural Network Architectures for High-Performance Spiking Neural Networks

Spiking Neural Networks for Computational Intelligence: An Overview

To Spike or Not to Spike? A Quantitative Comparison of SNN and CNN FPGA Implementations

On the computational power and complexity of Spiking Neural Networks

Advancements in Algorithms and Neuromorphic Hardware for Spiking Neural Networks

SNNLP: Energy-Efficient Natural Language Processing Using Spiking Neural Networks

Rethinking the Performance Comparison Between SNNS and ANNS.

PT-Spike: A Precise-Time-Dependent Single Spike Neuromorphic Architecture with Efficient Supervised Learning

Recent Advances in Scalable Energy-Efficient and Trustworthy Spiking Neural networks: from Algorithms to Technology

An Efficient Software-Hardware Design Framework for Spiking Neural Network Systems

Progress and Benchmark of Spiking Neuron Devices and Circuits