A carbon efficiency approach for laser welding environmental performance assessment and the process parameters decision-making

Zhuo Huang,Huajun Cao,Dan Zeng,Weiwei Ge,Chengmao Duan
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00170-021-07011-8
IF: 3.563
2021-04-09
The International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology
Abstract:As a new generation of manufacturing technology, laser welding is widely applied in the fields of automobile, aerospace, etc. with its compelling advantages of high flexibility, quality, and energy density. However, the environmental performance of the laser welding process is not clear so far. There is a lack of systematic analysis of the laser welding process that takes all the energy sources and material consumption into consideration to reflect the actual environmental impact and evaluate the process parameter for decision-making. In this study, a parameterized model linking the carbon emissions and laser welding parameters is established. Based on this, a carbon efficiency evaluation approach is proposed to reveal the trade-off between carbon emissions and the added manufacturing value for decision-making on the premise of ensuring the welding quality. To verify the effectiveness of this approach, the carbon efficiency of the laser butt joint welding process is analyzed as an illustration. The results show that the parametric carbon emission models offer a feasible evaluation of carbon emissions of the laser welding process, with an accuracy of approximately 93.6%. The carbon emissions of the cooling system are 1.78 times that of laser devices. Thus, it dominates the carbon emissions of the laser welding process rather than laser devices. While ensuring the processing quality, increasing the welding speed is the most key way to improve carbon efficiency. The reason for it is that the carbon emissions of auxiliary facilities, e.g., cooling system can be reduced significantly as the reduced welding time. Furthermore, the standby time used, e.g., clamping and taking-off of workpieces, etc., is another key factor affecting the carbon efficiency. Thus, shortening the standby time can also improve the carbon efficiency of the laser welding process.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the lack of systematic analysis in the environmental performance assessment of the laser welding process and the decision - making of process parameters. Specifically, the author points out that although laser welding technology is widely used in the automotive, aerospace and other fields and has the advantages of high flexibility, high quality and high energy density, its environmental impact is still unclear. In current research, there is no method that systematically considers all energy consumption and material use to comprehensively reflect the actual environmental impact and evaluate process parameters to assist decision - making. To solve this problem, this paper proposes a carbon efficiency approach, which links carbon emissions with laser welding parameters by establishing a parametric model, thereby revealing the trade - off relationship between carbon emissions and manufacturing added value. This method aims to provide a basis for decision - making on the premise of ensuring welding quality. To verify the effectiveness of this method, the paper also conducts a carbon efficiency analysis of the laser butt - weld welding process. The following are the specific problems that the paper attempts to solve: 1. **Lack of systematic analysis**: Currently, there is no systematic method to comprehensively consider all energy sources and material consumption to reflect the actual environmental impact of laser welding. 2. **Trade - off between carbon emissions and manufacturing added value**: A method is needed to evaluate the balance between carbon emissions and manufacturing added value to guide the selection of process parameters. 3. **Optimizing carbon efficiency while ensuring welding quality**: How to improve carbon efficiency and reduce carbon emissions while ensuring welding quality. ### Formula summary The formulas involved in the paper include: - **Total carbon emissions**: \[ CE = CE_{\text{laser}} + CE_{\text{cool}} + CE_{\text{motion}} + CE_{\text{gas}} + CE_{\text{wire}} \] where \( CE_{\text{laser}} \) is the carbon emission of the laser device, \( CE_{\text{cool}} \) is the carbon emission of the cooling system, \( CE_{\text{motion}} \) is the carbon emission of the motion system, \( CE_{\text{gas}} \) is the carbon emission of the gas device, and \( CE_{\text{wire}} \) is the carbon emission of the wire - feeding system. - **Carbon emission of laser device**: \[ CE_{\text{laser}} = CE_{\text{lsb}} + CE_{\text{lp}} = CEF_{\text{elec}} \cdot P_{\text{lsb}} \cdot t_{\text{lsb}}+\frac{P_{\text{lp}} \cdot t_{\text{lp}}}{\eta} \] - **Carbon emission of cooling system**: \[ CE_{\text{cool}} = CE_{\text{cl}} + CE_{\text{cs}} + CE_{\text{co}} = CE_{\text{cl}} + CEF_{\text{elec}} \cdot (P_{\text{cs}} \cdot t_{\text{cs}}+P_{\text{co}} \cdot t_{\text{co}}) \] - **Carbon emission of motion system**: \[ CE_{\text{motion}} = CE_{\text{ms}} + CE_{\text{mo}} = CEF_{\text{elec}} \cdot \left( P_{\text{ms}} \cdot t_{\text{ms}}+(P_{\text{ms}} + P_{\text{me}} + P_{\text{ml}}) \cdot t_{\text{mo}} \right) \] - **Carbon emission of gas device**: \[ CE_{\text{gas}} = CE_{\text{