Abstract:Purpose Email communication is indispensable for US state agencies to respond to citizen requests and engage with constituents, contributing to building trust in local governments. While prior studies examine the responsiveness of elected officials, the quality of virtual interactions between government organizations and citizens is often overlooked. This study aims to investigate how US government agencies capitalize on the potential of online interactions with constituents to manage generic queries and introduce the response engagement index (REI) consisting of response time, reactive transparency and message interactivity to evaluate levels of communicative engagement. Design/methodology/approach The authors conducted a field experiment encompassing emailing a request to 547 state agencies based in the five largest states and one small state. A total of 377 organizational responses were manually analyzed to reveal the usages of six communicative engagement strategies. Findings The results show the potential of online communication is underutilized as the average score of response engagement remains low. Human responses are less engaging than auto-reply messages and require a one-day waiting period, if not longer. Response types and gender of government communicators significantly differ in response time and engagement strategies. The findings identify divergent patterns of response engagement and provide practical implications for facilitating citizen engagement. Research limitations/implications This research fills a critical gap by investigating the quality of online interactions between US government agencies and citizens. The authors develop a theory-grounded tool of response engagement to identify three features: response speed, reactive transparency and interactivity. The findings can improve the quality of email communication in state agencies, enhancing governance quality. The REI proposed here addresses what Pfau (2008) deemed problematic for communication scholarship: research is sparse on “functional issues” that examine the communication process. Pfau argued for research that provides knowledge of interest across disciplines so as to “cross-fertilize” ideas between political communication and public relations; this study sought to bridge that gap with a theoretical and practical tool for building public trust in governments. Practical implications To support the evaluation of transparent and responsive governments, reliable and valid measurements are needed. The proposed REI provides practitioners with a theory-grounded tool to identify areas of engagement quality in government responses. The findings can be used to improve the quality of email communication in state agencies, enhancing governance quality. Social implications Citizens seek reciprocal dialogue through prompt, open and interactive communication. US state agencies should leverage the engagement features for increasing citizen trust – response time, reactive transparency and interactivity – when responding to public inquiries. Ultimately, trust in government agencies' interests in serving stakeholders cannot be strengthened without prompt and engaging responses to meet the public's needs. Originality/value This field experiment was one of the first to focus on US state agencies' responses to information requests. It introduces a new REI to assess communicative engagement in a government/citizen exchange.

Procedural environment of public engagement: an induced recall experiment of local government employees

Disentangling the Impact of Perceived Electronic Performance Monitoring on Employee Burnout in the Public Sector

Examining response engagement in online interactions between US government agencies and citizens

Generating employee engagement in a public–private partnership: management communication activities and employee experiences

Investigating the effects of high-involvement climate and public service motivation on engagement, performance, and meaningfulness in the public sector

The Perception of Environmental Information Disclosure on Rural Residents' Pro-Environmental Behavior

Public Participation and Effectiveness of Professional Climate Evaluation and Discussion-An Exploratory Study Based on the Perception of Organizations Evaluated

Measuring Individual Pro-Environmental Behavior Transformation: Contextualizing Individual Learning Behavior

Administering Public Participation

Procedural Justice and Employee Engagement: Roles of Organizational Identification and Moral Identity Centrality

Examining the nexus between social cognition, biospheric values, moral norms, corporate environmental responsibility and pro-environmental behaviour. Does environmental knowledge matter?

Residents' environmental behavior in eco‐community development and its influencing factors: Evidence from Dongying City, Shandong Province in China

Corporate environmental responsibility leads to more pro-environmental behavior at work by strengthening intrinsic pro-environmental motivation

Exploring key determinants of willingness to participate in EIA decision-making on urban infrastructure projects

The impact of environmental stimuli on the psychological and behavioral compliance of international construction employees

Linking Perceived Policy Effectiveness and Proenvironmental Behavior: The Influence of Attitude, Implementation Intention, and Knowledge

Research on Motivational Mechanisms and Pathways for Promoting Public Participation in Environmental Protection Behavior

Recruiting for Engagement in Health Policy

Identity and Guilt as Mediators of Pro-environmental Spillover

An Examination to Explain the Mechanism of Employees' Environment-Specific Behavior through CSR and Work Engagement from the Perspective of Stewardship Theory

Effects of recalling place memory on promoting cooperative behaviors in local communities