Abstract:Three-dimensional (3D) bioprinting, as a freeform biomedical manufacturing approach, has been increasingly adopted for the fabrication of constructs analogous to living tissues. Generally, materials printed during 3D bioprinting are referred as bioinks, which may include living cells, extracellular matrix materials, cell media, and/or other additives. For 3D bioprinting to be an enabling tissue engineering approach, the bioink printability is a critical requirement as tissue constructs must be able to be printed and reproduce the complex micro-architecture of native tissues in vitro in sufficient resolution. The bioink printability is generally characterized in terms of the controllable formation of well-defined droplets/jets/filaments and/or the morphology and shape fidelity of deposited building blocks. This review presents a comprehensive overview of the studies of bioink printability during representative 3D bioprinting processes, including inkjet printing, laser printing, and micro-extrusion, with a focus on the understanding of the underlying physics during the formation of bioink-based features. A detailed discussion is conducted based on the typical time scales and dimensionless quantities for printability evaluation during bioprinting. For inkjet printing, the Z (the inverse of the Ohnesorge number), Weber, and capillary numbers have been employed for the construction of phase diagrams during the printing of Newtonian fluids, while the Weissenberg and Deborah numbers have been utilized during the printing of non-Newtonian bioinks. During laser printing of Newtonian solutions, the jettability can be characterized using the inverse of the Ohnesorge number, while Ohnesorge, elasto-capillary, and Weber numbers have been utilized to construct phase diagrams for typical non-Newtonian bioinks. For micro-extrusion, seven filament types have been identified including three types of well-defined filaments and four types of irregular filaments. During micro-extrusion, the Oldroyd number has been used to characterize the dimensions of the yielded areas of Herschel-Bulkley fluids. Non-ideal jetting behaviors are common during the droplet-based inkjet and laser printing processes due to the local nonuniformity and nonhomogeneity of cell-laden bioinks.

Computation of Hydrodynamic and Capillary Phenomena in Binder Jet Three-Dimensional Printing

Coupled CFD-DEM simulation of interfacial fluid–particle interaction during binder jet 3D printing

Binder jetting additive manufacturing: Three-dimensional simulation of micro-meter droplet impact and penetration into powder bed

A Hybrid Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics Coupled to a Fictitious Domain Method for Particulate Flows and Its Application in a Three-Dimensional Printing Process

Binder jetting of SS316L: a computational approach for droplet-powder interaction

Computational Study of Extrusion Bioprinting with Jammed Gelatin Microgel-Based Composite Ink

High-Speed X-Ray Imaging of Droplet-Powder Interaction in Binder Jet Additive Manufacturing

Simulation of Binder Jetting and Analysis of Magnesium Alloy Bonding Mechanism

Binder jet 3D printing—Process parameters, materials, properties, modeling, and challenges

A versatile SPH modeling framework for coupled microfluid-powder dynamics in additive manufacturing: binder jetting, material jetting, directed energy deposition and powder bed fusion

Simulation of Binder Infiltration in Additive Manufacturing of Sand Molds

A coupled thermo-mechanical material point model of binder jetted green part sintering

Evaluation of Bioink Printability for Bioprinting Applications

An Extensive Study of the Influence of Key Flow Variables on Printed Line Quality Outcomes during Aerosol Jet Printing Using Coupled Three-Dimensional Numerical Models

A Comprehensive Investigation of Process Parameters and Material Properties Effects on Printed Line Quality of Aerosol Jet Printing Based on Coupled Three-dimensional Numerical Models

Modeling of Powder Bed Deformation in the Binder Jetting Technology

Many-body Dissipative Particle Dynamics Simulations of Nanodroplet Formation in 3D Nano-Inkjet Printing

Modelling of 3D concrete printing based on computational fluid dynamics

A Systematic Thermal Analysis for Accurately Predicting the Extrusion Printability of Alginate-Gelatin-Based Hydrogel Bioinks

Study on powder particle behavior in powder spreading with discrete element method and its critical implications for binder jetting additive manufacturing processes

Modeling extrusion process and layer deformation in 3D concrete printing via smoothed particle hydrodynamics