Systematicity in Organizational Research Literature Reviews: A Framework and Assessment

Zeki Simsek,Brian Fox,Ciaran Heavey

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/10944281211008652

IF: 8.247

2021-05-04

Organizational Research Methods

Abstract:In this study, we first develop a framework that presents systematicity as an encompassing orientation toward the application of explicit methods in the practice of literature reviews, informed by the principles of transparency, coverage, saturation, connectedness, universalism, and coherence. We then supplement that conceptual development with empirical insights into the reported practices of systematicity in a sample of 165 published reviews across three journals in organizational research. We finally trace implications for the future conduct of literature reviews, including the potential perils of systematicity without mindfulness.

management,psychology, applied