Theatre of Deferral: The Image of the Law and the Architecture of the Inns of Court

David Evans

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1023/a:1008834110997

1999-01-01

Law and Critique

Abstract:This article addresses the architecture of the Inns of Court, the home of the Common Law. The approach taken, however, rejects an approach that would reduce the Inns to a roster of historical details and laudatory description. Instead, the Inns are seen, if not actually felt, as the embodiment of the “original” ground of law. This experience is revealed through a three-stage discovery process that (1) situates the Inns within the medieval context of symbol and ritual as informed by Turner’s concept of liminality; (2) analyzes the space of the Inns using concepts of bodily disunity derived from the psychoanalysis of Lacan and Klein; (3) relates this space to the “body of Law” in phenomenological terms, as a function of the irresolvable priority of either arché or anarché. The article concludes with a series of speculative propositions on a series of originary architectonic sites: the labyrinth (Daedolos and origin of the city), the pinnacle (the figure of justice or the body of the blind woman), and the door (Kafka’s “Before the Law”). These culminate in the assertion that the architecture of the Inns of Court stages the deferral of bodily interiority through which the Law simultaneously derives its infinite remove and its authority.