Modes of therapeutic relationship in brief dynamic psychotherapy: A case study

John Nuttall

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/1353333021000038854

2002-01-01

Psychodynamic Practice

Abstract:More and more clinical studies demonstrate that theoretical approach has little to do with the effectiveness of psychotherapy; it is the quality of the therapeutic relationship that potentiates the beneficial effects. This prompted Clarkson's extensive research of the literature, which distinguished discourse about five modes or qualities of therapeutic relationship. These are: the working alliance, the transferential/countertransferential relationship, the reparative or developmentally needed relationship, the person-to-person or real relationship and the transpersonal relationship. This article presents Clarkson's framework and uses it to describe a case of brief dynamic therapy of a gay man with HIV. To show how this conceptualization of relationship provides 'a principle for integration between different approaches', the case is also described using mainly the perspectives of object relations and transactional analysis. The case describes how each mode of relationship came into focus at different times in the counselling process and how recognizing them permitted a more vibrant sense of, and respect for, the client's way of being, and his therapeutic journey. The article concludes that this relational perspective is not a theoretical approach in itself, but a way of reframing what goes on in the client-therapist encounter that transcends theoretical schools. As demonstrated in this case it provides a coherence and simplicity that concentrates and guides our understanding of the client's therapeutic needs.