Abstract:Models of numerical cognition consider a visuo-spatial representation to be at the core of numerical processing, the 'mental number line'. Two main interference effects between number and space have been described: the SNARC effect reflects a small number/left side and large number/right side association (number-location mapping); the size-congruity effect (SCE) reflects a small number/small size and large number/large size association (number-size mapping). Critically, a thorough investigation on the representational source for these two number-space mappings is lacking, leaving open the question of whether the same representation underlies both phenomena. Here, we build on a recent study (Viarouge and de Hevia in Front Hum Neurosci 15:750964, 2021) in order to address this question in three experiments, by systematically manipulating the presence of the two conditions that might elicit an interaction between SNARC and SCE: (i) an implicit task whereby numerical and spatial information are task-irrelevant, (ii) a design in which the number-space congruency relative to both mappings vary at the same level -either both within or between blocks. Experiment 1 replicated the interaction between the two mappings when both factors were present. Experiments 2 and 3 dissociated the two factors by varying the two mappings at the same level but using an explicit comparison task (Experiment 2), or by using an implicit task but with mappings varying at different levels (Experiment 3). We found that both factors, either in combination or used in isolation, drive the interaction between the two number-space mappings. These findings are discussed in terms of the weight given to each mapping, suggesting that a single representation encompassing both number-space mappings is therefore activated whenever both mappings are given equal weight through task requirements.

The mental representation of ordinal sequences is spatially organized

Spatial Representation of Ordinal Information.

A working memory account for spatial–numerical associations

The Spatial Coding Mechanism of Ordinal Symbols: a Study Based on the Ordinal Position Effect

Beyond the SNARC Effect: Distance–number Mapping Occurs in the Peripersonal Space

The Spatial Representation of One-digit Arabic Numbers

Numerosity Adaptation along the Y-Axis Affects Numerosity Perception along the X-Axis: Does Numerosity Adaptation Activate MNLs?

Numbers and space: A computational model of the SNARC effect.

The metaphoric nature of the ordinal position effect

Beyond fixed sets: boundary conditions for obtaining SNARC-like effects with continuous semantic magnitudes

Does the Spatial-Numerical Association of Response Codes Effect Depend on Digits’ Relative or Absolute Magnitude? Evidence from a Perceptual Orientation Judgment Task

The Association Between Number Magnitude and Space is Dependent on Notation: Evidence from an Adaptive Perceptual Orientation Task.

The Importance of Magnitude Information in Numerical Processing: Evidence from the SNARC Effect

What makes different number-space mappings interact?

Parietal Representation of Symbolic and Nonsymbolic Magnitude

Number, size, and space associated in a common system by distinct mechanisms

Is Order the Defining Feature of Magnitude Representation? an ERP Study on Learning Numerical Magnitude and Spatial Order of Artificial Symbols

Spatial-numerical association of response code effect as a window to mental representation of magnitude in long-term memory among Hebrew-speaking children

Influence of different spatial representations on the SNARC effect for letters: Electrophysiological evidence