Abstract:Crustacean fisheries represent an increasingly important contribution to global landings, food security and economic growth, especially in developing countries. However, many productive and valuable crustacean fisheries in Asian countries are characterized by limited data availability, scientific capacity, and fisheries management. Adaptive management frameworks, which use past and emerging information to provide stock status information and management advice, have been touted as particularly applicable for managing capacity- and data-limited fisheries because they employ methods that can improve data collection and result in evaluations of stock and ecosystem status with varying levels of data and capacity. Here, we examined the application of three adaptive fisheries management frameworks (FISHE, FishPath, and DLMtool) to three typical Asian crustacean fisheries that offered contrasting data types and availability, governance, and management and socio-economic contexts. Our aim was to evaluate their suitability for crustacean fisheries and identify particular data and modeling needs and management gaps in these fisheries. We found that while each of the frameworks could effectively recommend suitable monitoring, assessment, and management options given particular contextual factors, there were also limitations with each approach. For example, FISHE took a more wholistic view of ecosystem and fisheries heath, while the other frameworks were more focused on particular aspects of management such as stock assessment (FishPath) and management strategy evaluation (MSE; DLMtool). Applications of each approach also highlighted particular challenges in collecting commercial catch data due to limited monetary investment and poorly designed monitoring programs, which further hindered the implementation of catch and effort limits. The three frameworks also shared common challenges when applied to crustacean species, mainly associated with misalignment with the unique life-histories of crustaceans compared to finfish. By comparing the outputs of the three frameworks, we highlighted their respective strengths and weaknesses and propose an integrated framework that incorporates elements of each of the three frameworks. This integration offers a more comprehensive adaptive roadmap tailored to crustacean fisheries, which involves a mix of qualitative and quantitative approaches that could be applied depending on contextual factors and capacities. To further improve the applicability of adaptive frameworks to crustacean fisheries, we suggest considering crustacean's unique life history and the effects of climate change and other environmental factors, strengthening participatory processes, and balancing socio-economic and ecological objectives.

Examining fishery common-pool resource problems in the largest lagoon of Southeast Asia through a participatory systems approach

Sustainable aquatic resource management and inland fisheries in tropical Asia: Interdisciplinary and transdisciplinary approaches

How do governments respond to the social-ecological traps in small-scale fisheries and aquaculture? A case study in the Tam Giang lagoon, Viet Nam

Application of the Ostrom framework in the analysis of a social-ecological system with multiple resources in a marine protected area

Conflict and collective action in Tonle Sap fisheries: adapting governance to support community livelihoods

Understanding change, complexities, and governability challenges in small-scale fisheries: a case study of Limbe, Cameroon, Central Africa

An Analysis on Fishery Cooperation and Management Mechanism in South China Sea Region from the Perspective of Functionalism

Mental models of aquaculture governance in Indonesia

Political Participation and Small-Scale Fishery Management in the Tonlé Sap, Cambodia

Local fishery, global commodity: The role of institutions in mediating intersectoral conflict, cooperation, and competition in a globalized fishery

Competition or cooperation in transboundary fish stocks management: Insight from a dynamical model

Avoiding catastrophic collapse in small-scale fisheries through inefficient cooperation: evidence from a framed field experiment

Navigating the Complexity of Regional Ocean Governance Through the Large Marine Ecosystems Approach

Aquaculture innovation system analysis of transition to sustainable intensification in shrimp farming

Archetypes of community-based pond aquaculture in Indonesia: applying the social-ecological systems framework to examine sustainability tradeoffs

Research process of applying social-ecological system framework to overseas fisheries management

Evaluating adaptive management frameworks for data-limited crustacean fisheries

An Integrated Approach for Improved Management of an Island's Scarce Water Resources under Climate Change and Tourism Development

Tracing innovation pathways behind fisheries co-management in Vanuatu

Adaptive co-management in the Vietnamese Mekong Delta: examining the interface between flood management and adaptation

Fish passage across Southeast Asia: key informant insights into motivations and triggers for water resource planning and policymaking