Epistemic diversity and cross-cultural comparative research: ontology, challenges, and outcomes

Xin Xu
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/14767724.2021.1932438
2021-05-31
Globalisation, Societies and Education
Abstract:<span>This paper reflects on the transpositional comparison in Marginson and Yang's article in this special issue, with a focused discussion on epistemic diversity and cross-cultural comparative research. It argues that in global research, epistemic diversity largely co-exists with epistemic inequity and injustice, despite long-standing normative appeals. Against this backdrop, cross-cultural comparative studies have significant value, albeit facing a range of challenges. There are five outcomes of cross-cultural encounters: <i>assimilation</i>, <i>immiscibility</i>, and <i>being different together</i> (including <i>unity in diversity</i>, <i>harmony with diversity</i>, and <i>together with diversity</i>). Although East–West encounters demonstrated all possible outcomes, <i>being different together</i> is both possible and valuable, not only for East–West encounters but also for cross-civilisational comparisons.</span>
What problem does this paper attempt to address?