Study on Customer Loyalty in the Context of E-tailing Service Recovery --from the Perspective of Perceived Justice and Perceived Switching Costs
秦进,陈琦
DOI: https://doi.org/10.19616/j.cnki.bmj.2012.03.013
2012-01-01
Abstract:E-commerce has greatly changed traditional patterns of retailing. The prospect of enormous profit has attracted more and more enterprises and individuals to get involved in online retailing, which results in increasingly fierce competition. Nowadays, many online retailers have realized the importance of winning and maintaining customer loyalty. Due to the characteristics of online service, such as intangibility, heterogeneousness, simultaneity of producing and consuming, and easy-passing, online shopping failure is almost inevitable. Service failures are main obstacles that prevent e-retailers from building consumer loyalty. However, when service failure occurs, service providers can take this opportunity and use effective recoveries to transfer dissatisfied customers into satisfied ones, thus enhance customer retention rate and even build long-term relationships with customers. Therefore, e- tailing service failure and recovery management has become an important issue for both academics and practitioners. While scholars have extended service failure and recovery research to the field of e-commerce, many focused on the typology of online retailing service failure and recovery. As to the customer loyalty in the context of e-commerce, most studies have focused on the relationship between perceived quality, perceived value, trust, first satis- faction and loyalty. Only a few studies explored the formation mechanism of customer loyalty in the context of online service recovery. Previous studies have pointed out that perceived justice plays an important role in the formation of customer satisfaction and behavior intentions after service recovery, and creating brilliant customer satisfaction and enhancing switching costs are viewed as the two important means to gain customer loyalty for enterprises. In addition, studies have found that switching costs play a significant moderating role on the relationship between first satisfaction and loyalty, but whether switching costs have moderating effects on the formation mechanism of customer loyalty after service recovery remains as a problem that deserves to be further explored. Therefore, the goal of this study is to explore the relationship of perceived justice （ including distributive justice, procedural justice and interactional justice）, post-recovery satisfaction and perceived switching costs with online customer loyalty, and to validate the moderating relationship of perceived switching costs on the link between post-recovery satisfaction and customer loyalty in the context of e-tailing. Based on the existing theoretical results, a conceptual model explaining the relationship of perceived justice, post-recovery satisfaction and perceived switching costs with online customer loyalty is established, and a series of research hypotheses are proposed. Then a suitable scale is developed and a questionnaire survey on consumers who have experienced online service failure and recovery is conducted. With 235 valid samples obtained, variable relia- bility and validity testing results show that the measurement scale has an acceptable level of reliability and validity. Next, all hypotheses are empirically testified by the use of Partial Least Squares （PLS） structure equation model. Our results indicate that post-recovery satisfaction, distributive justice and perceived switching costs have directly positive influences on customer loyalty, while procedural justice and interactional justice have indirect effects on customer loyalty through post-recovery satisfaction ; each dimension of perceived justice has different impact on customer satisfaction after service recovery, and the impact of distributive justice on customer satisfaction is the greatest; perceived switching costs does not have a significant moderating effect on the link between post-recovery satisfaction and customer loyalty. Finally, according to the conclusions of the empirical research, some managerial implications are put forward. Limitations of this study and future research are also discussed. The findings of this study develop existing theories related to e-tailing service failure and recovery, and provide a valuable reference for managers of online shopping websites.