Abstract:As firms' pricing strategies increasingly rely on algorithms, two concerns have received much attention: algorithmic tacit collusion and price discrimination. This paper investigates the interaction between these two issues through simulations. In each period, a new buyer arrives with independently and identically distributed willingness to pay (WTP), and each firm, observing private signals about WTP, adopts Q-learning algorithms to set prices. We document two novel mechanisms that lead to collusive outcomes. Under asymmetric information, the algorithm with information advantage adopts a Bait-and-Restrained-Exploit strategy, surrendering profits on some signals by setting higher prices, while exploiting limited profits on the remaining signals by setting much lower prices. Under a symmetric information structure, competition on some signals facilitates convergence to supra-competitive prices on the remaining signals. Algorithms tend to collude more on signals with higher expected WTP. Both uncertainty and the lack of correlated signals exacerbate the degree of collusion, thereby reducing both consumer surplus and social welfare. A key implication is that the over-usage of data, both payoff-relevant and non-relevant, by AIs in competitive contexts will reduce the degree of collusion and consequently lead to a decline in industry profits.

Quality, Location and Collusion under Spatial Price Discrimination

Spatial Heterogeneity in Implicit Housing Prices: Evidence from Hangzhou, China

Urban/rural spatial price discrimination with online competition

The Agglomeration-Differentiation Tradeoff in Spatial Location Choice

Does Location Affect the Mechanism of Tourism Competitiveness? Evidence from Machine Learning Analysis

Public Firms on an International Border: A Model of Spatial Price Discrimination

Spatial Competition and Lowest Price Commitment

Spatial Pricing Patterns in the United States

Quality-price choices and market configurations when location matters

A Network-City Model of Spatial Competition

Spatial Competition and Social Welfare Considering Different Feasible Location Regions

Price Collusion or Competition in US Higher Education

Endogenous price discrimination with asymmetric firms

The Competition of Investments for Endogenous Transportation Costs in A Spatial Model

Spatial competition with unit-demand functions

Algorithmic Collusion and Price Discrimination: The Over-Usage of Data

Spatial price competition in the Manhattan hotel market: The role of location, quality, and online reputation

Analyses of location-price game on networks with stochastic customer behavior and its heuristic algorithm

New Dynamics of Spatial Distribution of Industries:Based on Firm Heterogeneity

Study of the horizontal competition of dual-channel retailer and traditional retailer with congestion negative effect of physical channel

Listing Prices As Signals of Quality in Markets with Negotiation